View Full Version : Bringing racial issues to the football forum
OK, the title makes it sound a little more controversial than it actually is, but in an attempt to salvage this forum from all the shit threads (Who's the best...., Official Official Thread etc...).
I thought I'd spark a debate about that favourite off topic subject, racial issues.
So who would win?
Black England or White England?
'Black' England
David James (possibly Shaka Hislop)
Glen Johnson, Sol Campbell, Rio Ferdinand, Ashley Cole
Wright-Phillips, Ledley King, Jermaine Jenas, Kieron Dyer
Carlton Cole/Darius Vassell, Jermaine Defoe
and for 'White' England
Paul Robinson
Gary Neville, John Terry, Jonathan Woodgate, Wayne Bridge
David Beckham, Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard, Joe Cole
Michael Owen, Wayne Rooney
"White" England would win just by a whisker...
but in premiership i think it would much diffrent
Kevthedrummer
08-09-2004, 18:19
Argh! This IS controversial! Probably white England for experience and black england for flare, plus you missed Heskey ;)
"White" England would win
What are you trying to say?
You think that makes white people better than black people? That the colour of someones skin makes them inferior to another race?
Racist!
I wouldn't want either to win. As playing Blacks Vs Whites ain't solving any racism is it ? And Shaka Hislop is from Trinidad Tobago you know! Same place Dwight Yorke is from or did you think the accent was fake :rolleyes: ?
nath_scfc
08-09-2004, 18:21
Good thread.
I reckon it'd be a close run thing. Either side could win it, probably dependant on form, currently I think Black England might just nick it.
Shaka Hislop plays for Trinidad & Tobago so I doubt he'd be able to play.
I desperately didn't want to include James.
Or perhaps I just didn't know Shaka's nationality.
Who knows.
Kevthedrummer
08-09-2004, 18:22
What are you trying to say?
You think that makes white people better than black people? That the colour of someones skin makes them inferior to another race?
Racist!
lol clever thread Liam K
What are you trying to say?
You think that makes white people better than black people? That the colour of someones skin makes them inferior to another race?
Racist!
wateva man i aint no racist unlike u who started this thread u asked a question i gave u a simple answer ppl these days :rolleyes:
I desperately didn't want to include James.
Or perhaps I just didn't know Shaka's nationality.
Who knows.
You didn't want to include James, because you were scared he will boost the Black England squad with his experience.
RACIST
Great Thread
The first team has a better defence but the latter has a very good attack.... to hard to call
o0oGedo0o
08-09-2004, 18:31
well do you think France would have actually done it in world cup 98 with only white frenchmen in their lineup? and without zidane who's origin is algerian ?
Kevthedrummer
08-09-2004, 18:32
Whoooooooooosh
lol whooooooooooosh indeed
well do you think France would have actually done it in world cup 98 with only white frenchmen in their lineup? and without zidane who's origin is algerian ?
Zidane was born in Marseille man, what more do you want?
o0oGedo0o
08-09-2004, 18:37
his parents are algerian, they moved to France 40 or 50 years ago, i don't really know but that doesn't make him 100% french, trezeguet is argentinian too right?
You don't have to be 100% one nationality to play for a country, therefore he's french, therefore he's eligable. If you had to be 100% then an awful lot of players would be ruled out of all international games and tournaments.
o0oGedo0o
08-09-2004, 18:45
You don't have to be 100% one nationality to play for a country, therefore he's french, therefore he's eligable. If you had to be 100% then an awful lot of players would be ruled out of all international games and tournaments.
i know that, i am just saying France didn't produce too many players in that generation that was worth of carrying the world cup, it was more of a world all star team than France national team, don't get so upset people France is my favorite national team ever so i wouldn't like to criticise them a lot i am just stating what's obvious
You don't have to be 100% one nationality to play for a country, therefore he's french, therefore he's eligable. If you had to be 100% then an awful lot of players would be ruled out of all international games and tournaments.
I bet Shevchenko, Giggs and Drogba wish they were some other nationalities as well, shame how such good talents have such a low chance of playing in major tournaments
o0oGedo0o
08-09-2004, 18:47
I bet Shevchenko, Giggs and Drogba wish they were some other nationalities as well, shame how such good talents have such a low chance of playing in major tournaments
Drogba plays with Ivory coast which are now first in the world cup qualifiers with 9 points 2nd comes Egypt, cameroon and lybia all with 7 points so they might have a good chance in qualifying this year
Zidane was born in Marseille man, what more do you want?
Yeah really. ;) Still tink Black England would win but it would be close.Kinda like Holland vs Czech Rep.Yup that good.
sam erasa
08-09-2004, 20:27
It wud probably be a draw then Black England would win on penalties.
this is a good thread i was thinking the same but wiith the best black players in the world playing against the best white players in the world, now that would be a game to watch.:D
Ketsbaia
08-09-2004, 20:57
Yeah really. ;) Still tink Black England would win but it would be close.Kinda like Holland vs Czech Rep.Yup that good.
Maybe that's because you're being racist. WHITE POWER! :rolleyes:
Maybe that's because you're being racist. WHITE POWER! :rolleyes:
LOL. :cool:
LOL. :cool:
whats so funny about that ? Or are you trying to hide something ?
whats so funny about that ? Or are you trying to hide something ?
No its just that the irony is potent.I laugh because his comment was whimsical not because i belive in it. :D And no i not hiding anything. BLACK POWER ALL THE WAY. :D
Fisherman
08-09-2004, 22:17
Nationalities come and go but people will always be people
End of
Definitely Maybe
08-09-2004, 22:58
Nationalities come and go but people will always be people
End of
Your only gay if you shag men? People will always be people?
Full of wisdom today eh marra? ;)
Kevthedrummer
08-09-2004, 23:22
Giggs COULD play for England, he chose Wales though right? Or maybe I'm wrong I seem 2 remember hearing it somewhere, he'd be the answer to Englands left side :D
Scarface
08-09-2004, 23:24
Giggs COULD play for England, he chose Wales though right? Or maybe I'm wrong I seem 2 remember hearing it somewhere, he'd be the answer to Englands left side :D
yeh he played 4 1 of Englands youth teams but then decided 2 play 4 Wales i think.
Kevthedrummer
08-09-2004, 23:39
yeh he played 4 1 of Englands youth teams but then decided 2 play 4 Wales i think.
and he's white too!
Fisherman
09-09-2004, 01:11
Your only gay if you shag men? People will always be people?
Full of wisdom today eh marra? ;)
Tell me Im wrong
Claiming people are gay just because they are well spoken and don't look like and sound like louts
Giggs could NEVER play for England, he is in no way english. The only 'England Team' he played for was the England schoolboys, and thats because he went to an english school, not because hes english, cos hes not.
vBulletin® v3.8.2, Copyright ©2000-2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.