PDA

View Full Version : Is this not out?

h108grd
29-04-2005, 10:35
I was Italy, and had a shot that bounced off a Czech Rep. Defender, and ran all the way to the touch line, and I thought this would be a corner to me??
Is this not out? I thought as long as 1/2 the ball is over the line, then it's over, and I should have a corner????
Barry
29-04-2005, 10:38
The full width and length of the ball have to over the line, but my version always give a throw in anyway.
Damn thing wont obey the rules :)
IRONS, IRONS
29-04-2005, 10:38
the whole ball needs to be over the line
h108grd
29-04-2005, 10:52
oh rite, thx guys for correcting me, i m still stuck in the stone age of football rules :P
Homer J.
29-04-2005, 11:21
I had exactly the same when I scored a goal. The keeper held it just the way on your picture, but the ref gave a goal...
boro 4eva
29-04-2005, 11:56
altough peolple have said the whole ball has to be over the line and thqat is correct i would still say that that was out of play!!
fluke88
29-04-2005, 12:55
I would say all of the ball was over the line, that has happend to me before but i scored at the end of it :).
soliloquay
29-04-2005, 12:59
i think it was out by a difference of a hair. it seems like it wasn't out from the view h108grd took the picture so it makes it look like it's in. parallax errors you know ;)
lukas86
29-04-2005, 16:55
I was Italy, and had a shot that bounced off a Czech Rep. Defender, and ran all the way to the touch line, and I thought this would be a corner to me??
Is this not out? I thought as long as 1/2 the ball is over the line, then it's over, and I should have a corner????

Man you were robbed. the rule is the whole of the ball has to cross the line and the image proves that it was. unlucky.
Hunter
29-04-2005, 17:26
In that case, yes. The whole ball was over the line for a start so I really do think you have been screwed over :D

But that has happened to me a couple of times, especially with goalkeepers because when they are holding the ball they are unable to take it out due to there being a forcefield. :rolleyes:
h108grd
29-04-2005, 17:43
Thx for your thoughts guys, anyways, even in the real world, the linesman does not always make the correct decision anyways, so i guess this is sort of similar case, as when it happened to u guys, somteims it was given and sometimes it's not..
Hunter
29-04-2005, 17:59
Yeah your right mate.
Sometimes you get, sometimes you don't.

But its a bitch when your screwed aint it. ;)
Nedy
29-04-2005, 23:08
Is really out mate.......the Pes have much bugs.......or not?
h108grd
30-04-2005, 11:14
well, it's always like that tho, aint it? when u want it, u dont get it...