PDA

View Full Version : Is this legal?


Lesliect6
09-09-2005, 21:35
Is it legal to publicly distribute compilations in which the music is not originally made? Isn't this violation of the copyright?

Alan Smith
09-09-2005, 21:38
What speak english.

Marrison
09-09-2005, 21:51
What speak english.
It makes perfect sense.

No-one will know whereabouts you got it from, so just go for it. Most of the compilations on the site have music on there, haven't a clue whereabouts that music comes from.

We could probably guess.

1,000th Post.

yusuf eeli
09-09-2005, 21:54
What speak english.

It makes perfect sense.


Exactly

I'm sure no-one will sue you unless your very very rich and worth suing..

What Marrison said was right because no-one will know where you got the music from.

ge4ce
10-09-2005, 08:28
One more reason is that (in the most compilations) audio is compressed is such way you wouldn't want to ripp the song from compilation because of the bad sound quality, so you're not distributing something that others would like to have.

This is actually advertising for the author of that song. I know that, because members often ask me who is the author of the song in my compi (and name of the song) and then they go to buy it because they want a prefect sound quality song. Of course, some of them "bought it" without paying, but that's their problem :D

Lesliect6
10-09-2005, 12:51
Thank you guys!!

pbchillin
10-09-2005, 13:12
What speak english.
Here you go Alan Smith, i have translated it for you:
Iz it legal to make vidz in which the muzik is not done by me? Will the pigs be at me door if i does?

Kevthedrummer
10-09-2005, 18:09
Also, you're not making any money on it (or if you are then you are breeching copyright) so it's no problem really, they have bigger fish to fry

becks001
26-11-2005, 14:42
Here you go Alan Smith, i have translated it for you:
Iz it legal to make vidz in which the muzik is not done by me? Will the pigs be at me door if i does?
Thats the funniest thing i've heard all day lol

Schmutz
05-12-2005, 15:38
Iz it legal to make vidz in which the muzik is not done by me? Will the pigs be at me door if i does?

Fantastic:)