Friendly- Yossi v Muad'Dib

[Yossi]

Yossi

----------------Green------------------
---------------------------------------
---Young---Toure---Upson---Lizarazu---
---------------------------------------
-----------Rivera---Perrotta------------
---------------------------------------
----Mendieta---Aimar-----Yeste--------
---------------------------------------
-----------------Mutu-----------------

Subs:
Carlos Kameni
Hatem Trabelsi
Sylvinho
Gabriel Milito
Gonzalo Rodriquez
Maxi Rodriguez
Vicente
Ruben Baraja
Marcos Assuncao
Raul Tamudo
Diego Forlan


Muad'Dib

http://img511.imageshack.us/img511/6977/4332bu.jpg (http://imageshack.us)


I would like opinions if possible on:

-The personnel in the defence and midfield. What do you make of them?
-The front four. How do you think they (in particular Mendieta) are suited to playing there?

[Phatmann2003]

Tareq for me. The only part of his team I'm not sure on is the wide players: babel and luis garcia, but I'd still say Tareq has the better team with Marquez Deco and Van Bommel in midfield :mellow:

However, I still think Yossi's team is decent and if on top form would make it very tough for Muads team with great creative players like Aimar and Mendieta. Muad for me overall still though.

[Itachi-san]

I think I will go with Muad on this one. Muad's team is well rounded and his midfield is packed solid with amazing players.

[Ronaldo 9]

Yeah me too, Muad got the better midfield there and Adriano is better than Mutu IMO..

[Nedy]

I go to Tareq too.....my opinions:
Yossi: The defense is great, but I prefer Milito and Rodriguez like CB and Sylvinho for Lizarazu.....my formations for your team is this:

--------------------------------Green-------------------------------
----------------------Milito--------------Rodriguez------------------
Young-------------------------------------------------------Sylvinho
---------------------Rivera-----------------Perrotta-----------------
-------Mendieta-----------------Aimar-----------------Vicente------
--------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------Forlan------------------------------

Muad: Your team is awesome......great defense, excellent midfield and excellents forwards too......nice formation too.....

[David P]

Got to go with Maud on this one your midfield would control the game bro!;)

[Keyser Soze]

Yossi:

I think Milito should slot at the back with Toure and Sylvinho at left back. I think your midfield should look something like this:
---------Perrotta--------
-Mendieta---------Vicente
----------Aimar--------

With Mutu and Forlan upfront, very strong team though who would put up a great battle in midfield.


Muad:

What can I say? Quality team, although, I would play 4-4-2 with Cisse and Adriano, the pace and strength of them two would be too much for most defences in the league.


I think Muad would win this one, but Yossi's team wouldn't go out with a fight and could cause Muad's defence many problems. But with Marquez also protecting the back four and such as great compact midfield, I think the match sways in Muad's favour.

[Scarface]

-The personnel in the defence and midfield. What do you make of them?
-The front four. How do you think they (in particular Mendieta) are suited to playing there?

Quite strong, but I think you should use Kameni, Trabelsi and Sylvinho instead of Green, Young and Lizarazu.

The front 4 are good, but i'd like to see Maxi Rodriguez in place of Mendieta.

I feel Muad would take this as his team looks a little stronger in most departments and the midfield trio could dominate, but Yossi has a strong looking squad which seems to have all areas covered and could have a good season in D2, definitely promotion candidates.

[Yossi]

Judging by my opinions, and the opinions of you all, you have actually caused me more selection problems than I had when I first posted this. Oh well.