D1 Matchday 4: Reyes vs vanNistelrooy

[Scarface]

Reyes

-------------------------------Given--------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------
------Nélson----------Ayala------------Chivu-----------A.Cole-------
--------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------Alonso---------Cambiasso---------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------
----Maxi Rodriguez--------------------------------------Ribery-------
--------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------Reyes-----------------------
-----------------------Torres---------------------------------------


Subs: Cech, Puyol, Lampard, Rooney, Henry

vs

vanNistelrooy

---------------------------1 Dida----------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------
---2 J.Zanetti----6 Brown---------4 Lucio------3 Lahm--------
--------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------5 Emerson-----------------------------------
-------------------------------17 Valeron---------------------
---18 Scholes---------------------------------14 Stankovic---
-------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------10 Owen---------9 Tevez-------------------

SUBS
13 Carlo Cudicini
15 Marek Jankulovski
16 Michael Carrick
7 Allesandro Del Piero
8 Dean Ashton

[Del Piero]

Im not sure about this one ill think about it and vote later

[Rambo]

Reyes to win.

[Nedy]

James wins here. Both defense are similiars, very solids, so here is a draw.
But James has a better midifeld IMO. Cambiasso and Alonso looks more strong duo than Valeron and Emerson. Also, in the sides, Maxi and Ribery are more fasters, and I dont consider Scholes as a good RMF.
In the attack James wins clearly. With Tevez and Owen in a bad form, vN lost here.

[Billy Minof]

James the Fucker with his super squad...lol.

We will have to pray for a disaster on his part IMO to take his title. :)

[Hunter]

This would be a good match here. I can see James taking the win, he's superior in the all important central midfield. Despite Scholes having a great season, I wouldn't be too confident playing him on the right as he lacks a cutting edge of pace. He'll have a hard job too against Ashley Cole (gayboy) so I can't really see such a key player making an impact. I think Reyes/Torres would be a good combination, not so sure about Owen/Tevez, could be hit and miss but it seems quite threatening if they can slip their man. Overall though, James takes it.

Good match guys, I think a 1 goal difference is a fair result.

Reyes 2-1 Ruud

[martin_cranie]

I think Reyes will take this one, but it will be close. To my mind, vNistelrooy's line-up still doesn't look that good. Your midfield has a poor balance and I doubt your ability to hold shape while supporting the front men. Keeping the same formation, I'd make the following changes:

-------------------------13 Cudicini--------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------
---2 J.Zanetti------4 Lucio--------23 Worns--------3 Lahm---
-------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------5 Emerson----------------------------------
-------------------------------17 Valeron--------------------
---18 Stankovic-----------------------------15 Jankulovski---
-------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------10 Owen---------7 Del Piero-----------------

There's a much better balance to that team, I think.

Reyes' team is it's usual dominating self, with the only real weakness being Nelson, and even he's pretty good.

I'm going to say 2-1 James.

[mufcsean]

Reyes for the win, as per usual his squad is better than the oppositions, especially in midfield