Friendly| PEM vs NYRB

[PEM]

PEM

http://i157.photobucket.com/albums/t56/hitesh_02/formi2copy.jpg
Subs:
Green,Bovo,Ferrari,Nery,Mcshef frey,Plasil,Lincoln,Petit,Card ozo,Viana,Santa Cruz,Kone

Questions

Is this my strongest side?
Muamba or Petit?
Do you think from my forwards i have picked the best 3?
From my center backs, have i pickedthe best?
From my whole squad, who is the weakest player?


NYRB


-----------------------------Andres Palop--------------------------
-------------------Chris Samba-------- A. Lopo--------------------
Bosingwa-----------------------------------------------Capdevila
-------------------------------------T. Motta---------------------
------------------------R. Pires-----------------------------------
T.Barnetta-------------------------------------------Harry Kewell
--------------------------------------Eduardo Da Silva--------------
---------------------Maciej Zurawski-------------------------------

Subs: Mido, Bouma, Alberto Rivera Pizarro, Fabrizio Miccoli, Henri Camara, Salihimidvic, Modesto, Christian Lell, Dudu Aouate, Marco zoro, Marco Marchionni

My Questions

Where am I the weakest?

If I had to lose one striker, which one?

This is my best midfield?

[Cali]

PEM:

Is this my strongest side?
No I wouldn't say so, I personally think that you should play Petit instead of Muamba, maybe Lincoln instead of Jenas and try and place Bovo at the back.

Muamba or Petit?
Personally, I prefer Petit.

Do you think from my forwards i have picked the best 3?
Yeah. I haven't seen Gekas play much, though..

From my center backs, have i pickedthe best?
Erm.. tough one. I rate Bovo, as when he plays for AS Roma he's usually great. Maybe swap him with Simic ?

From my whole squad, who is the weakest player?
Muamba, Jenas or McSheffrey ( Although, he'll probably perform this Season ).


NYRB:

Where am I the weakest?
Hmmm, defence.

If I had to lose one striker, which one?
Henri Camera.

This is my best midfield?
Looks solid. I would place Marchionni in there though.

[PEM]

oo forgot to do your question nyrb

Where am I the weakest?
defense for sure

If I had to lose one striker, which one?
yeh, like cali said, camara

This is my best midfield?
yes.


EDIT: oh and thanks alot cali ;)

[Scarface]

Is this my strongest side?

I don't think so. I would make the following changes: Bovo for Upson, Petit for Muamba, Lincoln for Jenas, Arouna Kone for Gekas, and then swap positions with Frei so he'd be attacking from the flank.

Muamba or Petit?

Petit

Do you think from my forwards i have picked the best 3?

They're all good, but I would prefer a frontline including Kone and Arango, with either Frei or Gekas the out and out striker.

From my center backs, have i picked the best?

Already answered...

From my whole squad, who is the weakest player?

Although he might have been impressive last season, probably McSheffrey.


Where am I the weakest?

They're both powerful defenders, but the centre of defence looks the weakest area.

If I had to lose one striker, which one?

Henri Camara

This is my best midfield?

Based on talent, yes. Based on balance, maybe not. Pires can't tackle, so I would go for a midfield four of: Barnetta-Rivera-Motta-Pires. Then again, Rivera isn't very good defensively, but at least has more experience of playing in the centre. Might be wise to purchase another established central midfielder.

EDIT: Actually, thinking about it, that probably would be your best midfield. Kewell would win more votes than Rivera, so stick with that.

[Keyser Soze]

Just echoing Cali's post but still....

Cali

Is this my strongest side?
Nope.
Muamba or Petit?
Petit
Do you think from my forwards i have picked the best 3?
Nah; Santa Cruz ahead of Gekas
From my center backs, have i pickedthe best?
Yeah.
From my whole squad, who is the weakest player?
Mcsheffrey.

---
NY

Where am I the weakest?
You're defence.
If I had to lose one striker, which one?
Camara
This is my best midfield?
Probably.

[Calzone]

Is this my strongest side?
I think lincoln should be in there somewhere.
Muamba or Petit?
Petit
Do you think from my forwards i have picked the best 3?
I think so
From my center backs, have i pickedthe best?
Maybe hard to tell. I would of started them as well.
From my whole squad, who is the weakest player?
jenas

[PEM]

thanks scarface, the g and nyrb

i see your keeping it simple the g :Laugh: ;)

[Dragonfly]

PEM:

Is this my strongest side?
- No (look below). I think Veron is nowhere as confident as he used to be. I'm sure he still has class though. Maybe have Lincoln ahead of Jenas, since people seem to prefer him, although I think Jenas isn't as bad as people make out.

Muamba or Petit?
- Petit.

Do you think from my forwards i have picked the best 3?
- Not really. Arango and Kone out wide, with Gekas upfront.

From my center backs, have i picked the best?
- I like Upson, but Bovo is also good.
From my whole squad, who is the weakest player?


NYRB:

Where am I the weakest?
- Defence, probably.

If I had to lose one striker, which one?
- Camara, I guess. I don't know what's happened to him.

This is my best midfield?
- Difficult to say. They're you best midfielders, but like Scarface said, Pires ain't the best tackler, but that doesn't seem to make Scholes a bad player. Motta isn't the best DM, so maybe drop either Barnetta or Kewell to put Pires out wide, and maybe put Bouma in DM to sure things up.

[Calzone]

This is my best midfield?
- Difficult to say. They're you best midfielders, but like Scarface said, Pires ain't the best tackler, but that doesn't seem to make Scholes a bad player. Motta isn't the best DM, so maybe drop either Barnetta or Kewell to put Pires out wide, and maybe put Bouma in DM to sure things up.

Would Lell or Salihamidzic be better for that role?

Thanks for the comments everyone.

Edit: Happy now The G. lolz

[Keyser Soze]

Would Lell or Salihimidvic be better for that role?

Thanks for the comments everyone.
Do you mean Salihamidzic? :mellow:

[Dragonfly]

Would Lell or Salihamidzic be better for that role?

Thanks for the comments everyone.

I'm not sure about Lell, I think he's better as CB. Salihamidzic could be very good, he can play pretty much anywhere, but I think he's better in attacking positions, including attacking full-back.

[Calzone]

Thanks.:)

:blush:

[martin_cranie]

Is this my strongest side?
Not quite. You have to bring in Petit for Muamba. I'd also consider using Ferrari at CB in place of Upson, but that's debatable.

Muamba or Petit?
Petit.

Do you think from my forwards i have picked the best 3?
I'd go with what you have there, but replace Frei with Kone.

From my center backs, have i picked the best?
Not necessarily. As I've said, Ferrari may be worthy of inclusion ahead of Upson.

From my whole squad, who is the weakest player?
Probably McSheffrey.

---

Where am I the weakest?
Central defence.

If I had to lose one striker, which one?
I'm really not sure.

This is my best midfield?
Possibly. I think Pires should be out on the left in place of Kewell - who I don't think will ever get back to anything like his best. Then again if most people are mistaken enough to believe otherwise, you should probably keep Kewell in and go with what you have.