View Full Version : The First Wild West Wars - "Thread West Redemption"
I do see your point.
But on the other hand, it is quite a badass picture :lol:
Of course he can't vote for you, Ali :lol:
The whole sig situation just seems too much to be a coincidence. You'd think the same if you saw someone with a Grat Dalton signature, right DF?
I could vote by proxy :)
Voting by proxy is a convenient way of voting if you are unable to get to the polling station. 'By proxy' just means that you appoint someone you trust to vote on your behalf. To vote by proxy, you’ll need to be registered to vote. Then just fill in an application form, sign it, and send it back to your local electoral registration office.
http://www.aboutmyvote.co.uk/register_to_vote/apply_to_vote_by_proxy.aspx
Daytime starts tonight so you can vote for whoever you want.
Daytime starts tonight so you can vote for whoever you want.
Well, I might vote tonight, if a few more people start to come round to the idea of voting DF. Having said that, Sminky hasn't posted the write up yet.... I might have been lynched, so I'll wait a bit.
Night 3 summary.
Although a busy enough night there is not a death to report.
Day 4 Begins.
Bammers has been revived and returns to the game.
Fantastic news all round.
Hopefully that means the role blocker done his job and he now can identify at least one member of the Dalton Gang.
And Bammers being back in a huge coup for us.
Fantastic!
Unless I'm mistaken, this must be our first net gain over a night-time period in Mafia/Wild West Wars?
smudger2008
16-04-2011, 22:20
so still no evidence to go on whatsoever. Might aswell be the first day again.
Brilliant news, the ultimate win-win really. Do we know why Bammers is back anyway, didn't someone make a post quite a few pages back asking to be replaced? I'm guessing this is the reason?
Welcome back Bammers brother. :cool:
As Joel has mentioned too, we can only assume the roleblocker did his job last night, and might have a little incling as to who may be involved in the Dalton Gang.
Brilliant news, the ultimate win-win really. Do we know why Bammers is back anyway, didn't someone make a post quite a few pages back asking to be replaced? I'm guessing this is the reason?
Welcome back Bammers brother. :cool:
As Joel has mentioned too, we can only assume the roleblocker did his job last night, and might have a little incling as to who may be involved in the Dalton Gang.
Well Sminky didn't mention if Bammers was taking anyone else's place or not. Could you clear that up for us Smink?
smudger2008
16-04-2011, 22:23
Brilliant news, the ultimate win-win really. Do we know why Bammers is back anyway, didn't someone make a post quite a few pages back asking to be replaced? I'm guessing this is the reason?
Chelsea did, but sminky told him to wait.
Bammers was revivied (as you was in the last game), if he replaced somone sminky would have said that.
As Joel has mentioned too, we can only assume the roleblocker did his job last night, and might have a little incling as to who may be involved in the Dalton Gang.
role blockers not gonna come out now and put himself in the firing line, we have the same numbers in the game as the beginning.
Awesome.
He said he was revived Papa, i'm sure Sminky would have said if he just replaced someone?
Anyway, last time round I think there was a life giver, but he could only use his ability once, so whoever that is, well played I think.
Chelsea did, but sminky told him to wait.
Bammers was revivied (as you was in the last game), if he replaced somone sminky would have said that.
role blockers not gonna come out now and put himself in the firing line, we have the same numbers in the game as the beginning.
Yeah. That's the most difficult job, trying to convey what you know without being obvious. When I was the cop a few games ago, I decided not to declare myself the cop and I was hounded because of it. :laugh:
The role blocker shouldn't come forward. He has a target now. He knows what he has to do.
We need him in the game and if he comes forward, he'll be killed.
Bammers05
16-04-2011, 22:28
http://www.esquire.com/cm/esquire/images/green12-zombie-hand-0409-10162228.jpg
smudger2008
16-04-2011, 22:29
so now we wait again and see if one of us gets picked off.
so now we wait again and see if one of us gets picked off.
No, we pick someone off.
I think we all need to start talking about our suspicions, so the roleblocker can guide us towards the Daltons.
The role blocker shouldn't come forward. He has a target now. He knows what he has to do.
We need him in the game and if he comes forward, he'll be killed.
Definitely. It's just suicide to come forward, and considering we're practically on day 1 again, it's way too early in the War to even risk a role so important.
smudger2008
16-04-2011, 22:33
No, we pick someone off.
I think we all need to start talking about our suspicions, so the roleblocker can guide us towards the Daltons.
I really hope we do lynch someone now, cus this game is so frustrating when you're a townie and nobody gets lynched.
EDIT: where is Dundons? does anyone know if he has been online all this time that he hasn't posted? he usually gets on to defend himself, but maybe he's avoiding that because I mentioned it?
Does anyone think its suspicous that bammers was dead and now all of a sudden he's alive :)
On a serious note, if he's been revived surely that means his role remains the same? so he's a townie again?
Or he's a zombie (cult) I remember sminky mentioning he had some supernatural ideas for the game and this would fit well with red dead redemption, i.e. undead nightmare
Dundon's was last on yesterday.
smudger2008
16-04-2011, 22:40
and he didnt even bother to defend himself? very suspicious, no?
1-1, two pens, wow
Bammers05
16-04-2011, 22:41
Does anyone think its suspicous that bammers was dead and now all of a sudden he's alive :)
Damn, I was hoping no-one had picked up on that :hmm:
On a serious note, if he's been revived surely that means his role remains the same? so he's a townie again?
Or he's a zombie (cult) I remember sminky mentioning he had some supernatural ideas for the game and this would fit well with dead read redemption, i.e. undead nightmare
All I've been told is that I've been revived, so I reckon I'm still a Texan, or a 'zombie Texan', if you like.
And, TH14, I'm afraid I'm gonna steal that avatar.
I don't know whether it is suspicious or just unfortunate that he probably can't be bothered to play anymore.
Does anyone think its suspicous that bammers was dead and now all of a sudden he's alive :)
On a serious note, if he's been revived surely that means his role remains the same? so he's a townie again?
Or he's a zombie (cult) I remember sminky mentioning he had some supernatural ideas for the game and this would fit well with dead read redemption, i.e. undead nightmare
This is too clever for smudger.
smudger2008
16-04-2011, 22:44
well he was keenly involved in the last game, even though he was busy.
This is too clever for smudger.
I've been dinking
So first Billy drops a hint about Hunter having his best ideas when he drinks, and now Smudger says that he's been drinking, and has had a really good idea?
:huh:. This is too clever for me.
Bammers05
16-04-2011, 22:51
Maybe you should drink, Dale?
smudger2008
16-04-2011, 22:51
he doesn't want to get banned again
Haha maybe I should Bammers, I did enough of that last night.
Can someone change the title to Day 4 please? Cheers
So where do we stand for later in the day (tomorrow in real time)?
Are people still suspecting DF is either Jesse James or affiliated, or not sold on the whole idea?
I'm not going to beat around the bush. I've said it before and I'll say it again, I find it too good for the signature to just be a coincidence. I don't trust DF at all right now.
muscularmatt
17-04-2011, 01:14
I vote Dale. He's a cunt of the very worst sort.
smudger2008
17-04-2011, 01:25
So where do we stand for later in the day (tomorrow in real time)?
Are people still suspecting DF is either Jesse James or affiliated, or not sold on the whole idea?
I'm not going to beat around the bush. I've said it before and I'll say it again, I find it too good for the signature to just be a coincidence. I don't trust DF at all right now.
I'll go with that, although it wasn't correct with hunters gay pinochio avatar.
I vote Dale. He's a cunt of the very worst sort.
FACT
:laugh: You didn't bold it so therefore it can't be a valid vote! This means that you, good sir, are a cunt of the master order!
But not smudger, who is just a plain old, unshaven, aids ridden cunt. Much like his dear old cunt mother, who is sucking Shaft's shaft as we speak.
muscularmatt
17-04-2011, 02:30
:laugh: You didn't bold it so therefore it can't be a valid vote! This means that you, good sir, are a cunt of the master order!
But not smudger, who is just a plain old, unshaven, aids ridden cunt. Much like his dear old cunt mother, who is sucking Shaft's shaft as we speak.
You're lucky I didn't bold it Dale, or else you'd have been well and truly fucked up. Although I do applaud the capitalisation on the first 'Shaft' as it was a proper noun.
Now fuck you all I have to be in work at 7am and I haven't slept a piss.
smudger2008
17-04-2011, 09:46
:laugh: You didn't bold it so therefore it can't be a valid vote! This means that you, good sir, are a cunt of the master order!
But not smudger, who is just a plain old, unshaven, aids ridden cunt. Much like his dear old cunt mother, who is sucking Shaft's shaft as we speak.
didn't bold it, you thick little midget, he has to post it in the voting thread for it to count, come on wee man get with it.
At the moment I suspect Dragonfly more than anyone. He just didn't defend himself well enough about the sig.
I'm not going to be on later so I'll be voting early (probably about noon) and at the moment, it will probably be for DF.
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 10:57
Night 3 summary.
Although a busy enough night there is not a death to report.
Day 4 Begins.
Bammers has been revived and returns to the game.
Fantastic news all round.
Hopefully that means the role blocker done his job and he now can identify at least one member of the Dalton Gang.
And Bammers being back in a huge coup for us.
Yeeeeeeeeeehaaaaaaaaaw, great night for us lads, Bammers back from the dead with a bald head, welcome back.
Good to see we have some members who can contribute, ie Role Blocker(but was the role blocked or did the Daltons just forget to kill one of us) and do we have a reviver or did Smink just decide to bring him back?
More questions than answers yet again.
so still no evidence to go on whatsoever. Might aswell be the first day again.
You dont sound too happy about the whole win/win for the town last night do you sir?
so now we wait again and see if one of us gets picked off.
Again?
This is too clever for smudger.
He is being very negative toward the good work of the town.
So where do we stand for later in the day (tomorrow in real time)?
Are people still suspecting DF is either Jesse James or affiliated, or not sold on the whole idea?
I'm not going to beat around the bush. I've said it before and I'll say it again, I find it too good for the signature to just be a coincidence. I don't trust DF at all right now.
At the moment I suspect Dragonfly more than anyone. He just didn't defend himself well enough about the sig.
I'm not going to be on later so I'll be voting early (probably about noon) and at the moment, it will probably be for DF.
Yeah, I agree, Dragonfly is the no 1 suspect, the only one that we actually have proof against so not voting for him would be madness, id like to know if Jesse James is a lone ranger though and if he could harm the Daltons like he harmed the Town. Either way though he is getting my vote, After that I am suspicious of Smudger.
You dont sound too happy about the whole win/win for the town last night do you sir?
He is being very negative toward the good work of the town.
Either way though he is getting my vote, After that I am suspicious of Smudger.
I totally agree, and not just because he called me a thick little midget (where is he getting his 'facts' from? At least I know for a genuine fact he's a fucking bin dipper!).
Very negative, always pushing for a lynch. I'm not totally sold on the DF stunt, but it was very suspicious. I'm looking at Smudger and DF mostly, and if everyone votes for DF then i'll be willing to help the cause, because I feel we really need a lynch soon.
For the GOOD of the town Smudger, not just for the sake of killing someone!
Dragonfly
17-04-2011, 11:50
It's not as simple as that though is it, or it at least doesn't seem to be. There's a difference between your avatar and your signature. Your avatar is so 'in your face' that nothing is hidden, or sneaky. It'd be almost too daring to have say Jesse James' face as your avatar. Whereas your signature displays not just Jesse James, but Jesse with a bandana over his face masking his identity, and doing so in such darkness that he's practically a silhouette. Then there's the now obvious fact the title Jesse James has been chopped from the image, which in some ways is a little understandable given sig sizes, but still.
It's a completely different situation than the avatar because the avatar is so brazen and bold, whereas the signature is so shrouded in mystery and darkness that no one even noticed it until several days in, and even then I found it through sheer pot luck. You can say I'm pushing this, and I'll agree, I am, to an extent, but at the end of the day you're the one who decided to change his signature to not just something questionable, but something incredibly suspicious, and you did so before the reveal of the Jesse James role in the game which is even more suspicious.
The actual image I used to make my sig was this (http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_8McfrvNvQQY/R4D4jlZibeI/AAAAAAAAAIY/57jmxfUgDhY/s400/2007_the_assassination_of_jess e_james_by_the_coward_robert_f ord_019.jpg) and not this (http://daleyus.files.wordpress.com/2010/11/brad_pitt_as_jesse_james2.jpg) , because of the difference in size. So, as you will see, there was not 'Jesse James' to crop from the image (although I did look for a Jesse James sig). Also, I did a bit of research to see when I changed my theme and it looks like it could've been hours before I received my role. Here (http://www.pesgaming.com/showpost.php?p=1745638&postcount=40) is when I when I was in the processing of updating my theme (at 18:27) and I received my role at 20:25 (click here (http://img836.imageshack.us/i/image1zb.jpg/)). The likelihood is that I didn't read that PM until the next day, at work.
The whole sig situation just seems too much to be a coincidence. You'd think the same if you saw someone with a Grat Dalton signature, right DF?
At the moment I suspect Dragonfly more than anyone. He just didn't defend himself well enough about the sig.
I'm not going to be on later so I'll be voting early (probably about noon) and at the moment, it will probably be for DF.
Dragonfly is the most likely target for me. I'm not convinced by his arguments when he was questioned about his sig.
I don't blame you guys for being suspicious, because I've clearly been naive with my sig. I guarantee you that you'll regret lynching me and will see that I am not Jesse James or in his gang. I think you guys are getting carried away with this a tad too much.
Perhaps I should've gone for the gay theme after all. :faceplm:
You know what, screw that. I believe Dragonfly.
Edit: I might add that this probably has no meaning now that everyone is going to vote for him, but he's just hit us up with facts and times? And there was Jesse James in his original image?
I think we should ask him a few more questions before jumping to lynch him.
Dragonfly, did you know that that image was originally from Jesse James, even without the writing in the bottom corner?
Dragonfly
17-04-2011, 12:01
You know what, screw that. I believe Dragonfly.
Edit: I might add that this probably has no meaning now that everyone is going to vote for him, but he's just hit us up with facts and times? And there was Jesse James in his original image?
I think we should ask him a few more questions before jumping to lynch him.
Dragonfly, did you know that that image was originally from Jesse James, even without the writing in the bottom corner?
Yeah, like mentioned in my posts, I had watched The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford a few days before WWW had started. I loved the film and once I knew there was a western themed Mafia Wars, I was in the mood to join (despite not playing since the very first MW). Then when I saw everyone change their avatars and sigs to western themes, I had no question in my mind what I was going to go for. I was oriinally looking for one of the day time shots, such as the fields of wheat/barley, but couldn't find anything good enough. I then found a picture from the scene of the train robbery whcih, I'm sure everyone would agree on, looks fucking awesome.
And you didn't think of the possibility of having one of the west's greatest ever antagonists as your avatar/sig wouldn't arouse suspicion? :lol:
Dragonfly
17-04-2011, 12:12
And you didn't think of the possibility of having one of the west's greatest ever antagonists as your avatar/sig wouldn't arouse suspicion? :lol:
I wasn't even thinking of that at the time, especially since I hadn't received my role yet. But like I said, it was naive of me. It's not like I could change my sig now or it would arouse even further suspicion. I'm resigned to the fact that I'm well and truly fucked. Is there a minimum number of votes for me to get lynched, or could one for me and none for anyone else be the end of me?
I'm surprised no one else suspects muscularmatt, to be honest. I thought he's be posting the shit out of this thread. Not that it will make a difference, but my vote will probably have to go to him, if I get anymore votes.
Yeah theres a majority vote, so we need a number of votes before you are lynched. Then you get a time period to declare your innocence one more time or something like that, i'm not sure.
Anyway, I don't think Dragonfly is guilty of anything to be honest, I just think it was a naive mistake having Jesse James involved in his sig. I'm sticking my neck out to defend the guy, there must be someone else willing to do the same?
Dragonfly
17-04-2011, 12:19
Cheers, Dale. Not that it'll make a difference. :(
I'm just going to keep an eye on this thread.
http://a21.idata.over-blog.com/0/60/35/71/album/lee-van-cleef.jpg
The whole deal with Dragonfly's sig just feels quite similar to Bammers fick's surprise bollocks from the last game, and we know what side Bammers was on. I'm not suggesting Hunter was thinking a similar way, I just think basing votes on a picture over general behaviour seems a bit over the top. I was actually very tempted to vote Dragonfly but having thought about it I don't see enough (right now anyway).
I count 14 (sporadically) active members so far. 8 Votes are required for a majority.
Dragonfly
17-04-2011, 12:38
I don't like the way no one is trying to look for other options. I suppose the onus is on me now.
I'm just looking at the list of participants and I'm surprised to see some of the usually active members not posting in here. I've mentioned muscularmatt, but an even more surprising one is Haribo, with only one post. I don't know what happened in the previous games, but I would've thought these two would be one of the biggest posters.
Anyway, I suppose all I can do now is pop into the saloon and have a drink and a smoke.
http://content9.flixster.com/photo/11/69/55/11695563_gal.jpg
I personally think we need to get rid of these lesser posters. All Matt has done is popped in and slated a few things (me included :laugh:) but as discussed, that's not really anything out of the ordinary.
It's where Laughin man and Appswah are concerned, that i'm concerned. They'll another set of easy kills (providing they aren't Dalton), which will leave us nothing to go on, and potentially 4 (including matt and Chelsea11) Texans down.
At the risk of sounding like a religious nutjob, we need to purge the game in order for us to actually have a chance of taking the upper hand at the end of this night. Yes, they may well be Texans, but I think they need to start posting, or feel some lead.
Edit: That's where I stand at the moment anyway, just letting everyone know.
EDIT: This is in addition to my smudger suspicion.
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 13:06
Hmmm, Dragonfly does have a good case but its hard to look past the obvious, if I had made that mistake(used a sig that could put me on the radar) and later found out that my sig could land me in trouble I would have 1)changed my sig or 2)explain my situation before someone spotted it, to come out after it and say you are innocent is easy.
I am suspicous of others also but if I dont vote for you now I probably never will and if in the end you do turn out to be Jesse James and we didnt lynch you we would look very silly, saying that you could also be Dalton(using a villian as your sig after the roles were given out) and the people defending you now are your alloys.
Im sticking with my vote, if anything it will give me peace of mind, if your guilty and turn out to be Jesse James then all the better for the town, if your a Dalton then we can see who is defending your name now and it will give us more to go on.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 13:12
Personally, I don't think we should lynch Dragonfly based purely on his sig. I can understand why people are suspicious about it, but I think it's clutching at straws to be talking about lynching him just for that - and there's no way I'm voting for him atm, unless other more conclusive evidence is found.
On the subject of avatars and sigs, I guess I should tell you guys my theory from when I was dead:
Basically, those of you playing will remember that a couple of games ago, we had the 'siblings' roles, where a townie and a mafia member were 'siblings'. They knew who the other one was and if one died, the other one would commit suicide the next day/night, I think. Anyway, there's a similar role known as 'lovers', which we haven't had in a game yet, I don't think. It basically consists of the same thing - 1 townie and 1 mafia, and if 1 dies, then the other kills themself the next day/night. Now, as we've all noticed, Ali has that picture from Brockeback Mountain as his avatar, which could, perhaps, be his way of hinting that he has that role. Of course, this is, also, just clutching at straws and I'd need to see far more substantial evidence, before considering voting for Ali, especially as he's one of the key contributors in the game, but I think it's worth making everyone aware of it.
As for who to lynch tonight, I'd be willing to go with one of the quieter ones, if we don't have any other conclusive suspicions. Personally, of those who haven't really contributed so far, I'd be most willing to lynch Matt, although I admit that part of the reason for that is that I'm still bitter about how he won in MW2.
So I'm the only dead guy?...
Hmmm, Dragonfly does have a good case but its hard to look past the obvious, if I had made that mistake(used a sig that could put me on the radar) and later found out that my sig could land me in trouble I would have 1)changed my sig or 2)explain my situation before someone spotted it, to come out after it and say you are innocent is easy.
I am suspicous of others also but if I dont vote for you now I probably never will and if in the end you do turn out to be Jesse James and we didnt lynch you we would look very silly, saying that you could also be Dalton(using a villian as your sig after the roles were given out) and the people defending you now are your alloys.
Im sticking with my vote, if anything it will give me peace of mind, if your guilty and turn out to be Jesse James then all the better for the town, if your a Dalton then we can see who is defending your name now and it will give us more to go on.
Yeah you are right Billy, it would make us look silly, but this game isn't about saving face it's about winning and beating the Daltons. I think 'defending' Dragonfly is not something that i'm consciously doing, i'm just defending a guy that has made a small mistake; you saw his argument, the times and what time he checked his role and whatnot, he could have easily missed the PM before he set his sig.
I don't know man, I don't think it's the right way to go to be honest.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 13:18
So I'm the only dead guy?...
Yes.
And I'm stealing your avatar.
Sorry :tongue:
I've already said that Matt is always worth a lynch. He hardly posts, when he does it's usually unhelpful bollocks and he never actually votes during the day. Even if he's a texan then at least it removes all the doubt and means 1 less silent poster in the game.
Crikey. Just caught up reading through the thread. I think the whole DF Sig thing is all just a big coincidence. I think everyone just jumped onto it as an idea because there was nothing else to go on.
Anyways, we do need to start the lynching else I fear the longer we leave it the harder it will be for us to win. However how we get people to all decide on someone I don't know. I'd be happy to vote for a quiet member if we have nothing else to go on.
The actual image I used to make my sig was this (http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_8McfrvNvQQY/R4D4jlZibeI/AAAAAAAAAIY/57jmxfUgDhY/s400/2007_the_assassination_of_jess e_james_by_the_coward_robert_f ord_019.jpg) and not this (http://daleyus.files.wordpress.com/2010/11/brad_pitt_as_jesse_james2.jpg) , because of the difference in size. So, as you will see, there was not 'Jesse James' to crop from the image (although I did look for a Jesse James sig). Also, I did a bit of research to see when I changed my theme and it looks like it could've been hours before I received my role. Here (http://www.pesgaming.com/showpost.php?p=1745638&postcount=40) is when I when I was in the processing of updating my theme (at 18:27) and I received my role at 20:25 (click here (http://img836.imageshack.us/i/image1zb.jpg/)). The likelihood is that I didn't read that PM until the next day, at work.
I don't blame you guys for being suspicious, because I've clearly been naive with my sig. I guarantee you that you'll regret lynching me and will see that I am not Jesse James or in his gang. I think you guys are getting carried away with this a tad too much.
Perhaps I should've gone for the gay theme after all. :faceplm:
You tell us the time of when you were 'processing your theme', but that doesn't really tell us much does it? It's unfortunate there's no real evidence of the time differences because it makes an argument for and against difficult. You can easily say it was the time that you have when you changed your entire theme to Western, but we all know there may have been hours inbetween changing the avatar and the sig. It's a difficult one to back yourself up on, but also difficult to slander you for of course.
Another point though is that you say "you'll see that I'm not Jesse James or his gang". So Jesse James has a gang now in this War? You'll have to do a little more explaining and answering here, but it seems like you might have saved yourself brother. Of course there's no hostility, and it may even just be a huge coincidence as we've all also pointed out, but I don't think you can blame me for bringing it up as I shit bricks when I seen the full wallpaper picture - it was like staring into the eyes of the Devil.
PS: That gay theme wouldn't have saved you at all by the looks of things now - and in fact may have caused more damage. :laugh:
But, I definitely agree with others in that we need to send the unwilling roaches of our town for the California Collar treatment. We need shot of the filth from the bottom of our boots, and in order to stamp them out of town, for the good of our future, I propose now making up a collaborative new shortlist. I think we can all assume Matt will be on there, Haribo, Appswah...who else deserves the ropá?
I actually didn't even realise that Haribo was in the game.
Matt, Haribo, laughin man and Appswah would be on the shortlist, in my eyes anyway.
Haribo isn't in the game chaps.
smudger2008
17-04-2011, 14:06
dundons should be added to the poisoned dwarfs list
Haribo isn't in the game chaps.
I knew it! Who said he was in it :faceplm:
dundons
Yeah Dundon's as well, but I think it's at risk of being a longlist rather than a shortlist.
Maybe if we can all agree on one person? At least we can sleep safe knowing that we've done something to try and save our necks, rather than just sit there and let the Dalton's make easy choices.
I knew it! Who said he was in it :faceplm:
:faceplm:
Someone said he was in the game a page or two back. I should never take anyone's word in here as gospel. Darn tootin' blabber mouths!
Let's see what everyone else says, but I think thankfully, we might be able to move forward from this day on as it seems we might be able to reach a vote today.
Chelsea11 has now left the game due to inactivity. Chelsea11 was a standard Texan role.
So we've lost a Texan for nothing, thanks dude :faceplm::faceplm::faceplm:
Not alot of choice really.
Should have negged him Sminky. *spits on the floor*
Should have kegged him Sminky.
We lost a townie in the last game when Football777 left. Might've helped me win if he stayed.
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 14:37
Personally, I don't think we should lynch Dragonfly based purely on his sig. I can understand why people are suspicious about it, but I think it's clutching at straws to be talking about lynching him just for that - and there's no way I'm voting for him atm, unless other more conclusive evidence is found.
On the subject of avatars and sigs, I guess I should tell you guys my theory from when I was dead:
Basically, those of you playing will remember that a couple of games ago, we had the 'siblings' roles, where a townie and a mafia member were 'siblings'. They knew who the other one was and if one died, the other one would commit suicide the next day/night, I think. Anyway, there's a similar role known as 'lovers', which we haven't had in a game yet, I don't think. It basically consists of the same thing - 1 townie and 1 mafia, and if 1 dies, then the other kills themself the next day/night. Now, as we've all noticed, Ali has that picture from Brockeback Mountain as his avatar, which could, perhaps, be his way of hinting that he has that role. Of course, this is, also, just clutching at straws and I'd need to see far more substantial evidence, before considering voting for Ali, especially as he's one of the key contributors in the game, but I think it's worth making everyone aware of it.
As for who to lynch tonight, I'd be willing to go with one of the quieter ones, if we don't have any other conclusive suspicions. Personally, of those who haven't really contributed so far, I'd be most willing to lynch Matt, although I admit that part of the reason for that is that I'm still bitter about how he won in MW2.
I brought that whole thing up a few days ago about the Gay Avatars being the bandits (arse bandits) and I still have my suspicions of them.....
Yeah you are right Billy, it would make us look silly, but this game isn't about saving face it's about winning and beating the Daltons. I think 'defending' Dragonfly is not something that i'm consciously doing, i'm just defending a guy that has made a small mistake; you saw his argument, the times and what time he checked his role and whatnot, he could have easily missed the PM before he set his sig.
I don't know man, I don't think it's the right way to go to be honest.
I am not doubting that his timing may have been off and his choice of Sig but then why not change it after Jesse James roles into town even though he was conscious that his Sig was of Jesse James, also the fact that it took him 2 days to come up with a alibi. As I said I have to stick with my vote out of principle and the only person I feel we can actually point our fingers at with any shred of evidence even if it is a mistake on his part.
I am usually all for eliminating the dead wood or people who dont post and I will probably vote for one of them tomorrow but with our only lead being Dragonfly I cant send a innocent man to the gallows.
So we've lost a Texan for nothing, thanks dude :faceplm::faceplm::faceplm:
Could be a good thing for us, yes its one less for the Daltons and Jesse James to kill but its also one less suspect for us to deal with and maybe clue that the inactive members are only inactive because they only received normal Texan roles?
Also, we are going to look like idiots if DF does indeed turn out to be Jesse James and we let him loose.
Should have kegged him Sminky.
Done.
Chelsea11 waved goodbye to the town with barrel in tow and dreams of fame and wealth.
Getting into the barrel at Niagra Falls the public gathered to watch the latest 'daredevil' attempt this feat of bravery/lunacy.
As we he waved to the crowd he shouted "Remember my name! First man to survive Niagra!"
He wasn't.
His remains to this day have never been found.
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 14:41
7 votes for a lynch then?
Nope, I factored in who was and wasn't posting when I arrived at 8 votes for a majority lynch.
Billy, DF would have looked even worse if he changed his signature.
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 14:55
Billy, DF would have looked even worse if he changed his signature.
Not if he explained why or even if he didnt change his sig but explained that his sig was of Jesse James and it wasnt to be read into that he had it before he JJ was introduced into the game but he chose to ignore the fact that JJ was now in play and was conscious that his sig was of JJ.
Maybe it wouldn't be so bad if he came forward and said, "I have Jesse James in my sig guys, I didn't know blah blah", or something like that, but suspicion would still be shining hard on him.
He was in trouble the moment Jesse James name was mentioned.
But it seems he will not be lynched and one of the quieter ones will go. I don't get this, because in the last game people were saying this is a mafia tactic, but now it seems so many people want to do it. I don't mind it, but it just comes across as double standards.
Maybe it is because they are so many quiet ones.
Phatmann
17-04-2011, 15:06
Chelsea11 has now left the game due to inactivity. Chelsea11 was a standard Texan role.
Sake. Does this have anything to do with Bammers being revived or was that done separately? Would've been ideal for Bammers to have taken his place as discussed a few days back then whoever was able to revive someone could have revived TH14 and we'd be at full strength apart from one inactive townie.
Maybe it is because they are so many quiet ones.
This is exactly it man. I see what you mean about double standards, but there are about 4 people who we've hardly seen in the game, yet alone the saloon.
Like I said it's a shortlist for a reason, there can't be too many people on it, but that's the way it is.
So we know Billy's all for voting for DF, Me and Bishop seem against voting for him and getting rid of one of the quiter ones, Hunter seems neutral, and Smudger has already voted DF.
Gah, we need other people online!
Sake. Does this have anything to do with Bammers being revived or was that done separately? Would've been ideal for Bammers to have taken his place as discussed a few days back then whoever was able to revive someone could have revived TH14 and we'd be at full strength apart from one inactive townie.
I wouldn't be too concerned ... yet ... Dundon's and Laughin' Man are on the Niagra Falls converyor belt of death too waiting to be pushed. I will review their situations from day to day. It is at my discretion after all and I do loathe to do anything that unbalances the game so I won't rush any decision.
muscularmatt
17-04-2011, 15:58
Who's on the block? I'll go for mob mentality.
^ You're on the block, Matt. Since you're going with mob mentality, are you prepared to vote for yourself?
muscularmatt
17-04-2011, 16:23
For reals? What I do wrong??
So we know Billy's all for voting for DF, Me and Bishop seem against voting for him and getting rid of one of the quiter ones, Hunter seems neutral, and Smudger has already voted DF.
Gah, we need other people online!
I think voting for DF on such evidence is abit silly. I think the main thing is we get a lynch by the end of the day even if it does consist of one of the 'quieter' ones.
For reals? What I do wrong??
Do you even have to ask?
Edit:
I'm off to work now so I'm sticking my vote in now.
Interesting to note that Appswah has voted Matt to make sure that Matt has the most votes, even when he's in a similar position.
Dragonfly has 3 votes to Matts 2.
8 Votes for a lynch.
When does voting close, Sminky?
I'm incredibly conflicted in terms of adding my vote here, because to be honest, I'd happily vote for several people who are suspiciously not pulling their weight. And if they are not pulling their weight, they are effectively dead weight. Weight which the Texans can only carry for so long before it becomes genuinely detrimental to the town's progress.
And then there's Dragonfly who is quite suspicious, even with his seemingly decent enough response, but it doesn't hide the fact his testament cannot actually be proven. He's got more shit going against him right now than he can actually shuffle away. It's a case of who's more dangerous to our existence; Jesse James, or the Dalton Gang?
There's so many dilemmas here; Dragonfly = Jesse James? But then there is the fact that there's probably several Dalton Gang members out there, and not to mention the dead weight of the non-contributing Texan town folk who are arguably hindering our progression as opposed to aiding the numbers. I think Buffalo Bill spat out earlier that by even eliminating a town member who's not contributing, it actually just means that it's also one less question mark to solve, meaning it'll be easier to piece together the puzzle as our theories carry more certainty. It's a real dilemma, and without trying to sound too non-committal, I'd be prepared to see if we can come to a complete decision whether to play hangman with Dragonfly, or a lesser contributer in this WWW...
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 19:28
If there is a vote needed for a lynch then I will probably change my mind but tomorrow my vote will be for Dragonfly again as I have a very bad feeling about him now, as you said Joel, people have double standards and I feel a few of them could be throwing us off his scent because even if he isnt Jesse James he could be one of the Daltons and if we weed out one then it will be easy to weed out the others.
Dundon's
17-04-2011, 20:06
I have to apologise for my lack of activity in this one fellahs, I know I'm not much good to the game as am but I am still keeping the numbers in favour of the Texans if that's an consolation.
I'm gonna read back a few pages now and try catch up on what's going on, but the Dragonfly/Signature conspiracy has got my attention already. Not sure I'm ready to commit to hanging him out to dry just yet though.
I will read more. -.-
Voting as it stands
Dragonfly 4
Matt 2
Dundon's
17-04-2011, 20:21
Dundon's was last on yesterday.
Correction, my Girlfriend was online yesterday, I'm always logged in automatically when you click the tab bar bookmark, she reads the off topic section but is mostly reading the movie thread.
I'm gone terrible when it comes to riding the waves. TBH this is the only forum I even bother with.
Appswah voting for matt really has me stumped. I think because of this, i'm going to vote dragonfly.
Appswah hasn't posted all game really, and is in the same position as matt, yet when Appswah sees that Matt's name is banging around a bit, so he votes for him, even though he's formed no conclusion on the matter? That doesn't sit right with me. This makes it look like Matt is a Texan and Appswah is a Dalton and he's just trying to jump on a lynch bandwagon in order to get a quick kill.
I'm not ready for that to happen, so i'm going to vote Dragonfly, for obvious reasons. Sorry for the turnaround fella's, but what Appswah did doesn't sit right with me at all.
I've also thought of something else. I think whoever got the Jesse James role isn't going to be one of the quiet ones because they'd have a role which is interesting (more so than a straight Texan anyway :() so they might want to post a bit more. At least more than some people have done already. At the same time Jesse James wouldn't want to attract too much attention because people are aware that it's a suspicious role, so I don't think he would have been the highest poster either.
It is through that theory that I think Jesse James is a member who has posted a medium amount. It might not seem like much :lol: But I know what I mean.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 20:36
One question that hasn't been asked is what exactly is the 'Jesse James' role? What powers does the role incorporate? And most importantly, which side are they on? These are the questions I'd like to know the answers to, before I vote for Dragonfly, because it seems to me that if this Jesse James role is neither Texan nor Dalton, then I don't understand what advantage would be gained by us getting rid of someone suspected of having it, at this moment in time.
Dale mentioned Appswah's vote for Muscularmatt and I agree with him that this seems strange and it's almost as if Appswah, who's barely posted all game, is trying to jump on the bandwagon to vote for Matt. Because of this, my prime suspect is now Appswah, rather than Matt and I'd like us to lynch him.
Jesse James in not pro Texan nor pro Dalton. He's either by himself, or he is the head of his clan.
If the theme of this game follows the real life, then he is a murderer just like the Daltons.
He already screwed us over on Day 3, I don't want to be screwed over again.
Phatmann
17-04-2011, 20:43
One question that hasn't been asked is what exactly is the 'Jesse James' role? What powers does the role incorporate? And most importantly, which side are they on? These are the questions I'd like to know the answers to, before I vote for Dragonfly, because it seems to me that if this Jesse James role is neither Texan nor Dalton, then I don't understand what advantage would be gained by us getting rid of someone suspected of having it, at this moment in time.
That's what I was thinking when reading through this thread. The Jesse James role may have stopped us from lynching anyone but doesn't seem to have had the ability to kill anyone off yet so maybe it's even some sort of defensive townie role? However, due to the non activity last night, maybe he was just blocked by someone from carrying it out? At this stage it looks like Dragonfly is the only one close to a lynching at the moment and perhaps it would be wisest to lynch him in case it does turn out that this Jesse James role can be harmful to the town once again in the future.
Dale mentioned Appswah's vote for Muscularmatt and I agree with him that this seems strange and it's almost as if Appswah, who's barely posted all game, is trying to jump on the bandwagon to vote for Matt. Because of this, my prime suspect is now Appswah, rather than Matt and I'd like us to lynch him.
I didn't think anyone would actually agree with me, but I really think we should vote for Appswah as well! It's just too suspicious man.
I'm not happy with voting for Dragonfly, but we need a community vote, and it looks like everyone has gone for Dragonfly/matt.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 20:46
I've voted Appswah, Dale, so there's one vote for him. If I had to choose between lynching a possible Mafia member and a possible 'Jesse James', then I'd go with the former and that's what I believe we must do.
Yeah I was literally just thinking that i'd rather try and get a possible Dalton member gone, rather than Jesse James. As phats said, he hasn't killed any of us yet... :hmm:
I'm voting Appswah :ohmy:
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 20:53
Also, if we lynched and he was a Dalton, it would, surely confirm that Matt's a Texan?
Yeah that's exactly my theory. Which would leave us in a bad place because then jesse james will know hes a texan and then we'll be one number down, that is it jesse james has any killing power :faceplm:
Anyone else see mine and Bammers' way of thinking, or is everyone still hung up on the dragonfly thing?
I voted Dragonfly but then changed vote because of what Appswah did. Come on guys!
Also, if we lynched and he was a Dalton, it would, surely confirm that Matt's a Texan?
It would confirm he isn't Dalton, but he could still be third party.
I'm not really getting the "forget about Jesse James" vibe going around. He used his power on Night 2 to screw us over on Day 3. Who is to day that he won't use his power tonight (Night 4) to screw us over, or even worse, kill one of us tomorrow (Day 5)?
I will admit that Appswah is kind of suspicous though. But you all thought he was suspicious in MW2 as well, when he was pro town.
What I did notice though was that Appswah voted for Matt rather than DF. At the time, DF had more votes than Matt did (and still does). So if he is trying to just gain a lynch, then why did he pick the guy with the least votes?
Dale does bring up an interesting point. Why would Appswah vote for Matt when he's in pretty much the same situation? Very little posting, just coasting, and then votes for literally his mirror image (just about)...
Is this a ploy from possible mafia to turn attention away from Dragonfly onto Matt? Or is it simply a case of Matt being such an anus that he's developed so many enemies that not only is he suspicious based solely on his participation so far, but that it'd also actually be pleasing to see him being lynched regardless of whether he's a Texan, Bandit or Jesse James himself? :lol:
What I did notice though was that Appswah voted for Matt rather than DF. At the time, DF had more votes than Matt did (and still does). So if he is trying to just gain a lynch, then why did he pick the guy with the least votes?
Good point. Maybe he is in with Dragonfly. As of yet Sminky hasn't really threw up too many surprises, and from last game, i'm kind of expecting something fucking incredulous to happen tonight D:
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 21:08
You make a good argument, Joel tbf.
If DF had more votes, Appswah voting for Matt could just be him trying to take the heat off Dragonfly and I suppose they could be working together. I'm still leaning towards voting for Appswah, but I'm certainly becoming rather suspicious of Dragonfly.
We need more members online to see where everyone is leaning towards. It's no good with like 5 or so people :faceplm:
Right now, I don't trust either DF or Appswah. But Appswah's lack of posting, trying to lynch someone who is in the same position as him (Matt) and his refusal to vote for DF (or even say why he isn't) weighs up more in the favour to vote for him right now.
Well me and Bammers have voted for Appswah, so you know where we stand at the moment.
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 21:16
I'm not really getting the "forget about Jesse James" vibe going around. He used his power on Night 2 to screw us over on Day 3. Who is to day that he won't use his power tonight (Night 4) to screw us over, or even worse, kill one of us tomorrow (Day 5)?
I will admit that Appswah is kind of suspicous though. But you all thought he was suspicious in MW2 as well, when he was pro town.
Yeah, me too, this is the closest we have been so far to a majority vote and with the current standings we only need a couple of more and alot of questions will answered, dont forget we have only become suspicious of Appswah over the past hour or so while we have had DF on our radar since yesterday and we can vote for Appswah accordingly tomorrow or the following day whereas if JJ lives we may not have another chance to vote tomorrow night if he can only use his powers every second day.
We need the majority on this and I say change your votes to DF, become united as a Town and send a show of force to the varmets who are trying to bring down our good town.
Standing together we can become unstoppable, divided we are easy prey.
My mistake, he did say why he doesn't want to vote for DF.
Crikey. Just caught up reading through the thread. I think the whole DF Sig thing is all just a big coincidence. I think everyone just jumped onto it as an idea because there was nothing else to go on.
Anyways, we do need to start the lynching else I fear the longer we leave it the harder it will be for us to win. However how we get people to all decide on someone I don't know. I'd be happy to vote for a quiet member if we have nothing else to go on.
The truth is, it could be a coincidence (the sig). And maybe it is unfair to lynch DF on that basis.
We need more members online to see where everyone is leaning towards. It's no good with like 5 or so people :faceplm:
I think it's a case of us needing to actually get the ball rolling ourselves, and hope others log in and go with the majority which has happened since the beginning of our Great Wars and will probably continue to do so.
Right now, my eyes are on Dragonfly obviously, and Appswah. I can't help but think Dragonfly could be Jesse James, and Appswah a Bandit.
Either way my vote is obviously going for either Dragonfly or Appswah.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 21:21
I'm willing to change my vote to Dragonfly, if everyone else wants to go for him, but I'm still more suspicious of Appswah, personally.
I'm willing to vote Dragonfly. Even though basing a vote purely on a picture isn't that strong an argument, there doesn't seem to be many other options and we need a lynch tonight, for the sake of the game.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 21:30
These are the votes so far:
Dragonfly 4 (Papa, Buffalo Bill, Smudger, Joel)
Matt 2 (Dragonfly, Appswah)
Appswah 2 (Bammers, Dale)
Interesting that both Dragonfly and Appswah have voted Matt. It's almost as if they knew who they wanted to get rid of and felt we would vote for Matt too like sheep.
Well noted Bam-Bam (we should all have Western nicknames!).
Could it be that my suspicion of Dragonfly being Jesse James is wrong, and he's actually a Bandit along with Appswah who we all seem to believe is a potential Bandit anyway? This War is certainly getting more interesting by the hour.
It's got to be Dragonfly or Appswah I think. It's got to be who we're more likely to reach the majority vote number (8?) with as well doesn't it - should we all agree to it of course.
I'm lost of all of a sudden. I don't think either is mafia/Dalton, but I think they could be thrid party. But then, we don't know if thrid party is just one member.
Aaahhhhh.
We have just under 20mins to go. What do you guys want to do?
I think if we lynch Appswah and he is third party, then DF is definitely Jesse James. But if we lynch DF and he is Jesse James, that doesn't exactly mean Appswah is a member of his group.
Dundon's
17-04-2011, 21:36
Right I'm up for voting Apps, we can always keep the Dragonfly conspiracy for another day if we get some stronger evidence against him.
I'm sticking by my vote. I really didn't like the way Appswah voted, and Bammers just stated that DF also voted for Matt?
It's very suspicious man.
Bammers..
http://www.nacremedia.com/uploads/1277664300-lee-van-cleef.jpg
Agreed. It's got to be Appswah right now:
1 - People think he maybe Dalton
2 - If he is a member of JJ's clan then he would point us in the direction of DF
3 - There isn't really a 3, but you don't just put 1 and 2!
I'm going to lay my vote down on Appswah (edit), because I'm equally suspicous of Appswah and Dragonfly, and I think it'd be even more disastrous if we fail to reach the required vote leaving us with no lynch - that would be awfully hard to swallow. It's rare that we have two suspicions for one lynching, so we should feel blessed, especially in a seemingly relatively early stage in the War.
I think Bam-Bam made a good point though with his Dragonfly and Appswah notion of them both voting for Matt - possibly on the back of several comments in the thread made about Matt potentially heading for the noose, being on shortlists etc. Maybe they thought we'd cling to the notion and the wheels would start?
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 21:40
If Appswah is, in fact, just a regular Texan, then at least we haven't got rid of someone who contributes a lot.
So the way I see it, we must vote for him.
How long do we have left?
We have 8 mins left and we still need 2. We need Minof to change his vote and for someone else to come online.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 21:44
6 minutes, I think.
Current voting situation:
Appswah 6 (Bammers, Dale, Dundon's, Joel, Bish, Hunter)
Dragonfly 3 (Papa, Bill, Smudger)
Matt 2 (Dragonfly, Appswah)
If it gets to a couple of minutes left, we should all change our votes to Dragonfly imo.
I think Sminky said we needed 8 votes, but was this before Chelsea11 was removed or after, because didn't Sminky say he was basing his voting majority number on active members?
I'm honestly not sure the definite number we need, but we are more than capable of reaching 8.
4 minutes of voting remains. A further 2 votes required to Lynch Appswah.
Dundon's
17-04-2011, 21:47
Hold the fort lads!!!, I just got news through the telephone wire that a couple of strangers be heading through this part of the woods any time now...
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 21:48
I think we should change our votes to Dragonfly now.
EDIT: They better do it bloody quickly.
Are we sticking with Apps or swapping to 'fly??
That's it.
We got 8.
Fucking hell Billy :lol:
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 21:49
Ok lads, I changed my vote for the sake of the town, my suspicions are still very much on Dragonfly though and this must not be swept under the carpet.
John Wayne likes to keep the suspense up till the last minute. :)
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 21:49
Sticking with Apps, I think, Bish.
Voting closed. Appswah has 10 minutes to plea for his life.
my suspicions are still very much on Dragonfly though and this must not be swept under the carpet.
Agreed.
Laughin man came from nowhere.
Billy is trying to steal my last second vote brilliance.
Ok. This better pay off. But I really do think that Appswah linking himself to DF is key here. So we may get two results here.
God have mercy on our souls, if we just sent a noble Texan to the ol' rope.
Dundon's
17-04-2011, 21:52
There will be blood...
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 21:52
The shit hit the fan and splatters all over Appswah.
Talk about last second tension. Literally!
We never darn well learn. :lol:
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 21:57
Ok. This better pay off. But I really do think that Appswah linking himself to DF is key here. So we may get two results here.
God have mercy on our souls, if we just sent a noble Texan to the ol' rope.
Jesus we better be right for a few reasons, 1, we may lose a Texan, 2, we might not get a vote tomorrow night with JJ still running loose.
Fingers crossed.
Talk about last second tension. Literally!
We never darn well learn. :lol:
Never will I think.
laughin man
17-04-2011, 21:59
I seen the smoke signals and came as quickly as I could :happy:
Day 4 Summary:
A day that seemingly had the name of Dragonfly across its noose quickly changed off the back of one post by Appswah. The Texans united and in speedy fashion voted for Appswah to hang. Dragging kicking and screaming Appswah was beaten with horse shoes until his jaw hang shattered from his skull.
Strung up, his identity was revealed.
Appswah was (although historically inaccurate :)) Frank Dalton, leader of the Dalton Gang. His special ability was appearing innocent in the event of being investigated.
The first Dalton Bandit has been killed.
Night 4 begins.
You have until 22:35 to post your reactions.
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 22:05
I seen the smoke signals and came as quickly as I could :happy:
That smoke was coming from my tent, the peace pipe full of tweed. :ninja:
laughin man
17-04-2011, 22:07
http://inewp.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/northdakotacowboys.jpg
Fantastic!
I have to admit, I honeslty didn't see Appswah as a Dalton coming.
Props to Dale for bringing it up and then with Bammers help, pushing it through.
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 22:07
Day 4 Summary:
A day that seemingly had the name of Dragonfly across its noose quickly changed off the back of one post by Appswah. The Texans united and in speedy fashion voted for Appswah to hang. Dragging kicking and screaming Appswah was beaten with horse shoes until his jaw hang shattered from his skull.
Strung up, his identity was revealed.
Appswah was (although historically inaccurate :)) Frank Dalton, leader of the Dalton Gang. His special ability was appearing innocent in the event of being investigated.
The first Dalton Bandit has been killed.
Night 4 begins.
You have until 22:35 to post your reactions.
Yip, Yip, Yip..........Yeeeeeeeeeeeehaaa aaaaaaaaaaaw.
caxAXxnXQ68
EDIT: So we have a sheriff/cop who can investigate, things are looking better by the minute.
It's nice to also see one of the silent posters eliminated, with the added bonus of them not sailing through the game appearing to be innocent. Nice work lads.
The cowboys beyond the grave are proud.
Now... Why would a Dalton who is looking to lynch anyone against them, turn down the opportunity to go with the majority of votes and decline to vote for Dragonfly?
^ Topic for Day 5 in case I am killed tonight.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 22:14
Good job, guys. :)
Is it night-time now, Sminky?
Yes. This is the amnesty period of posting though.
Dundon's
17-04-2011, 22:15
This was a serious coup, now lets smoke out the rest of them.
It's nice to also see one of the silent posters eliminated, with the added bonus of them not sailing through the game appearing to be innocent. Nice work lads.
This is the most important thing. Hoping he could breeze through aye!
Now... Why would a Dalton who is looking to lynch anyone against them, turn down the opportunity to go with the majority of votes and decline to vote for Dragonfly?
^ Topic for Day 5 in case I am killed tonight.
Yeah good point.
Well done fella's, a successful first lynch!!
Fantastic stuff.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 22:25
When you guys are done with Appswah's corpse, can you give it to me? Zombie like brains :yum:
Also, it's worth pointing out that I don't think the Dalton's would vote en masse for their own guy, so let's have a look at those who voted for Appswah:
Bammers, Dale, Dundon's, Joel, Bish, Hunter, Laughin Man, Buffalo Bill
Therefore, I believe that the majority of the Daltons come from this group:
Phatmann, Fick, Smudger, Ali, Papa, Dragonfly
I, also, believe that Matt is a non-Dalton, because, otherwise, why would Appswah have voted for him?
This has got to be the greatest first lynch of all Wars! I really can't quite believe our judgement, especially to those who first mentioned it (Dale and then Bam Bam).
Eventually, everyone will succumb to Harmonica...
hL-X53ze5O0
EDIT: Excellent work again there Bammers. We really have this game by the fucking nuts this time.
I don't see how we can't weed out the Dalton Gang now. I imagine a spanner or two will be thrown into the mix, but as far as building from a solid foundation, we've the best tools we could ask for right now.
Bammers05
17-04-2011, 22:33
I totally expect to get killed again tonight btw.
Billy Minof
17-04-2011, 22:34
so let's have a look at those who voted for Appswah:
Bammers, Dale, Dundon's, Joel, Bish, Hunter, Laughin Man, Buffalo Bill
Therefore, I believe that the majority of the Daltons come from this group:
Phatmann, Fick, Smudger, Ali, Papa, Dragonfly
I, also, believe that Matt is a non-Dalton, because, otherwise, why would Appswah have voted for him?
So now we have our list of those who we should be voting for.
The Daltons are not going to be happy and I expect them to come out all guns blazing before dawn, im getting a good nights kip, its been a long day and we should all be proud.
EDIT: Doh, sorry Smink, I was looking for a video on Youtube and couldnt find one so my post is a tiny bit late. :(
Right, thats your lot for tonight gents. Posting is permitted again from 8pm tomorrow night. Laters.
Since I haven't had a chance to post today, I'll just pop in and say when done lads. I very tiny ray of sunshine to and otherwise miserable day. Also, welcome back Bammers!
When you guys are done with Appswah's corpse, can you give it to me? Zombie like brains :yum:
Also, it's worth pointing out that I don't think the Dalton's would vote en masse for their own guy, so let's have a look at those who voted for Appswah:
Bammers, Dale, Dundon's, Joel, Bish, Hunter, Laughin Man, Buffalo Bill
Therefore, I believe that the majority of the Daltons come from this group:
Phatmann, Fick, Smudger, Ali, Papa, Dragonfly
I, also, believe that Matt is a non-Dalton, because, otherwise, why would Appswah have voted for him?
You do I know I've been to Wembley, right? (:crymore:)
laughin man
18-04-2011, 17:07
Since I haven't had a chance to post today, I'll just pop in and say when done lads. I very tiny ray of sunshine to and otherwise miserable day. Also, welcome back Bammers!
You do I know I've been to Wembley, right? (:crymore:)
Will I just shoot this punk right now Sminky?
Billy Minof
18-04-2011, 17:19
Im still laughing over the lynch last night, it was hilarious.:dancer:
laughin man
18-04-2011, 17:33
Once Clint and John Wayne rode into town it was all over
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 20:07
The credit for that successful lynching has to go to Dale for spotting Appswah.
Surely this puts dragonfly as the main target now. Or why didnt Appswah vote for him as he had the most votes at the time.
Billy Minof
18-04-2011, 20:08
The credit for that successful lynching has to go to Dale for spotting Appswah.
Surely this puts dragonfly as the main target now. Or why didnt Appswah vote for him as he had the most votes at the time.
We cant talk tactics until the day time pal, just freindly banter.
Sun rises on a new day. You may post as normal. Write up at 10pm.
Phatmann
18-04-2011, 20:12
Good work on lynching Appswah last night. When I was last on before the deadline it looked like we weren't gonna get a lynch as there were three separate targets - Dragonfly, Appswah and Matt - and I wasn't convinced that any were worth lynching at the time, although I was leaning towards Dragonfly. Hopefully we can have another successful night like we did the previous night.
Dragonfly definitely looks more suspicious now. But maybe he was telling the truth all along. He's probably not Jesse James. He looks more likely to be a mafia member now. Appswah not voting for him, whilst he had the most votes is key here.
Billy Minof
18-04-2011, 20:14
Good work on lynching Appswah last night. When I was last on before the deadline it looked like we weren't gonna get a lynch as there were three separate targets - Dragonfly, Appswah and Matt - and I wasn't convinced that any were worth lynching at the time, although I was leaning towards Dragonfly. Hopefully we can have another successful night like we did the previous night.
Hopefully none of us got took out last night, what about a Role Call for lets say 10pm. :erm:
EDIT: Great Credit to Dale, the little drunkurt spotted the needle in the haystack.
We have a hitlist to work off of now so we can narrow it down one by one, I think its now up to those we suspect to start defending themselves.
You know who you are.......
Phatmann, Fick, Smudger, Ali, Papa, Dragonfly
laughin man
18-04-2011, 20:15
The Daltons are coming for us shortly I reckon we take cover for now *spits on the ground*
Bammers05
18-04-2011, 20:18
My top suspicion is, surprisingly enough, Dragonfly. I'd be interested to hear his defence, but I think Appswah, through not voting for him, has basically written Dragonfly's death sentence. Dragonfly had the most votes at the time and if he wasn't a mafia member, then surely Appswah would have wanted to help us on our way to getting enough votes to lynch him? Instead, not only did he not vote for Dragonfly, he voted for someone else to try and take attention away from a possible lynching for him.
Hopefully none of us got took out last night, what about a Role Call for lets say 10pm. :erm:
EDIT: Great Credit to Dale, the little drunkurt spotted the needle in the haystack.
We have a hitlist to work off of now so we can narrow it down one by one, I think its now up to those we suspect to start defending themselves.
You know who you are.......
Phatmann, Fick, Smudger, Ali, Papa, Dragonfly
Well, like I've mentioned earlier (you obviously haven't been paying attention), I went to Wembley yesterday and didn't get back until 11:00pm, so I was unable to vote for Apps. I don't think I need to explain myself anymore.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 20:20
We cant talk tactics until the day time pal, just freindly banter.
thought it was 8 o'clock, didnt post till after that
laughin man
18-04-2011, 20:22
My top suspicion is, surprisingly enough, Dragonfly. I'd be interested to hear his defence, but I think Appswah through not voting for him has basically written Dragonfly's death sentence. Dragonfly had the most votes at the time and if he wasn't a mafia member, then surely Appswah would have wanted to help us on our way to getting enough votes to lynch him? Instead, not only did he not vote for Dragonfly, he voted for someone else to try and take attention away from a possible lynching for him.
I'll go with Dragonfly if I live long enough... and another thing I want Ali killed the next time if ye dont do it il shoot him myself, two cowboys huggin like that its not right I tell ya *spits on the ground*
Phatmann
18-04-2011, 20:23
Dragonfly definitely looks more suspicious now. But maybe he was telling the truth all along. He's probably not Jesse James. He looks more likely to be a mafia member now. Appswah not voting for him, whilst he had the most votes is key here.
Yes, this did seem rather odd. I'm sure we'll get more of an idea after the night activity. It will be interesting to see if Jesse James does anything else at this stage. I don't think anyone has carried out any killings other than the town and the Daltons yet have they?
Hopefully none of us got took out last night, what about a Role Call for lets say 10pm. :erm:
EDIT: Great Credit to Dale, the little drunkurt spotted the needle in the haystack.
We have a hitlist to work off of now so we can narrow it down one by one, I think its now up to those we suspect to start defending themselves.
You know who you are.......
Phatmann, Fick, Smudger, Ali, Papa, Dragonfly
Well I'll go ahead and defend myself then. Having looked through the pages that I missed yesterday, it seems that I'm a suspect because I didn't vote for Appswah. Well my reason for that is simply I was out all day. As I said at 10.26 am:
At the moment I suspect Dragonfly more than anyone. He just didn't defend himself well enough about the sig.
I'm not going to be on later so I'll be voting early (probably about noon) and at the moment, it will probably be for DF.
I don't think it was until Dale's post at 16:36 that suspicion turned to Appswah, hence why I voted Dragonfly (who I still certainly regard as suspicious).
If there's any other reason I should be on that list let me know and I'll answer any questions you may have.
My top suspicion is, surprisingly enough, Dragonfly. I'd be interested to hear his defence, but I think Appswah, through not voting for him, has basically written Dragonfly's death sentence. Dragonfly had the most votes at the time and if he wasn't a mafia member, then surely Appswah would have wanted to help us on our way to getting enough votes to lynch him? Instead, not only did he not vote for Dragonfly, he voted for someone else to try and take attention away from a possible lynching for him.
100%.
Nail on the head. I think as Joel also mentioned, it might even be the case of Dragonfly not being Jesse James, but a Dalton Bandit instead which seems almost certain at the moment from the voting.
I'll go with Dragonfly if I live long enough... and another thing I want Ali killed the next time if ye dont do it il shoot him myself, two cowboys huggin like that its not right I tell ya *spits on the ground*
The man doth protest too much :laugh:
As far as this game is concerned, I only have two things on my mind:
1 - Seeing the results of Night 4
2 - If I am alive for Day 5, lynching DF
After that, I don't know who is a suspect and who is not. But I know 3 people who are definitely not Dalton.
The man doth protest too much :laugh:
:laugh:
"No, not without lube!!!"
:laugh::laugh::laugh:
Bammers05
18-04-2011, 20:37
As far as this game is concerned, I only have two things on my mind:
1 - Seeing the results of Night 4
2 - If I am alive for Day 5, lynching DF
After that, I don't know who is a suspect and who is not. But I know 3 people who are definitely not Dalton.
Who?
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 20:38
As far as this game is concerned, I only have two things on my mind:
1 - Seeing the results of Night 4
2 - If I am alive for Day 5, lynching DF
After that, I don't know who is a suspect and who is not. But I know 3 people who are definitely not Dalton.
I think we can safely assume Dale and Matt are not dalton gang now, but lets no forget about Jesse James.
Who?
I think we can safely assume Dale and Matt are not dalton gang now, but lets no forget about Jesse James.
I actually forgot about Matt. So 4 for me - Bammers, Dale, Dundon's and Matt.
Minof and laughin man, look unlikely as well.
Bammers is the only texan I am sure of, due to his previous death.
Bammers05
18-04-2011, 20:47
I actually forgot about Matt. So 4 for me - Bammers, Dale, Dundon's and Matt.
Minof and laughin man, look unlikely as well.
Bammers is the only texan I am sure of, due to his previous death.
Be careful - I may have been inducted into a cult, if there is one, so I don't think we can be sure that anyone's a Texan.
I agree with you on those four though. I would go as far as putting Buffalo Bill and Laughin Man in there as well.
laughin man
18-04-2011, 20:48
Be careful - I may have been inducted into a cult
:realmad:
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 20:48
I actually forgot about Matt. So 4 for me - Bammers, Dale, Dundon's and Matt.
Minof and laughin man, look unlikely as well.
Bammers is the only texan I am sure of, due to his previous death.
Interesting that you didnt include yourself in the people you know not to be daltons ;)
I dont see how dundons is safe?
and voting at the last minute, when it already looks likely is just a good way for the mafia to try to look unconnected, dondons voted for amateur last game when they were in the same mafia. But you would already know that Joel as you was in the same family as well.
EDIT: I wouldnt be surprised in Bammers role has been changed, doubt sminky would bring him back as such as sitting duck.
I don't think I'm ever going to get revived :\ someone put me in a huge block until they build a machine which can bring me back to life!
laughin man
18-04-2011, 20:51
Interesting that you didnt include yourself in the people you know not to be daltons ;)
I dont see how dundons is safe?
and voting at the last minute, when it already looks likely is just a good way for the mafia to try to look unconnected, dondons voted for amateur last game we they were in the same mafia. But you would already know that Joel as you was in the same family as well.
EDIT: I wouldnt be surprised in Bammers role has been changed, doubt sminky would bring him back as such as sitting duck.
Dundons sent the smoke signals out to me and Minof so you could credit him with the lynch. Take what ye want from that *spits on the ground*
and voting at the last minute, when it already looks likely is just a good way for the mafia to try to look unconnected, dondons voted for amateur last game we they were in the same mafia. But you would already know that Joel as you was in the same family as well.
Dundon's is definitely not a Dalton.
Yesterday, time was running out and we didn't look like we were going to get the Appswah lynch. But I think Dundon's told laughin man and Minof to come online and vote for him.
If he was a Dalton, he wouldn't have done that. He had already voted for Appswah and he could have left it as that. But he decided to make sure the lynch happened.
I think Joel's list is somewhat reasonable.
Dale is an understandable notion, what with him leading the charge for the Appswah lynch. Bammers I can somewhat understand too as it's been practically announced he re-entered the War as a Texan, although that was some days ago now. If Jesse James has a gang/cult then it's quite possible he's inducted at least 1-2 members by now no? What better member to induct than someone who everyone is strongly of the belief that he's a Texan?
Matt was obviously voted for by Appswah, and more importantly now Dragonfly too. So it seems very feasible that Matt is either a Texan or Jesse James as otherwise I don't think the Dalton Gang would have tried to create a surge to send him to the noose.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 20:57
Dundons sent the smoke signals out to me and Minof so you could credit him with the lynch. Take what ye want from that *spits on the ground*
will you stop spitting!
Dundon's is definitely not a Dalton.
Yesterday, time was running out and we didn't look like we were going to get the Appswah lynch. But I think Dundon's told laughin man and Minof to come online and vote for him.
If he was a Dalton, he wouldn't have done that. He had already voted for Appswah and he could have left it as that. But he decided to make sure the lynch happened.
OK
EDIT: will sminky be able to do a write up with the QPR match on?
:laugh:
"No, not without lube!!!"
:laugh::laugh::laugh:
They were real men back in the wild west! No need for your fancy lube!
Interesting that you didnt include yourself in the people you know not to be daltons ;)
I dont see how dundons is safe?
and voting at the last minute, when it already looks likely is just a good way for the mafia to try to look unconnected, dondons voted for amateur last game when they were in the same mafia. But you would already know that Joel as you was in the same family as well.
EDIT: I wouldnt be surprised in Bammers role has been changed, doubt sminky would bring him back as such as sitting duck.
Some good points there. But, regarding your last point, I wouldn't think that Bammers would have been brought back as a Dalton.... that would have been really unfair on us.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 21:00
They were real men back in the wild west! No need for your fancy lube!
Some good points there. But, regarding your last point, I wouldn't think that Bammers would have been brought back as a Dalton.... that would have been really unfair on us.
Doesnt have to be a dalton to be unsafe, as he said himself, he could be cult
Doesnt have to be a dalton to be unsafe, as he said himself, he could be cult
True.
They were real men back in the wild west! No need for your fancy lube!
Some good points there. But, regarding your last point, I wouldn't think that Bammers would have been brought back as a Dalton.... that would have been really unfair on us.
Bammers was brought back before the first Dalton was killed so I can't see how he could be. Unless he's joined as their long lost cousin.......
I'm just waiting for the night's activities. After that, it's hard to look anywhere else other than Mr. Fly at the moment.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 21:08
I think everyone should step up with their thoughts now so even if you are taken out we can still consider what you had to say.
I agree with most above DF was already suspicious and Appswah's actions have made it worse for him.
laughin man
18-04-2011, 21:17
will you stop spitting!
Iv been listening to this song since last night, that'l tell what sort of form im in *spits on the ground*
hL-X53ze5O0
Billy Minof
18-04-2011, 21:27
Dundons made the phone call and asked me to change my vote. I think anyone that voted for Apps is not Dalton although 1 or more could be or be part of Jesse James gang we just dont know yet but we do have a strong idea of who isnt Texan and I think we will have enough to go on by the end of the day.
I still suspect DF and I said yesterday that he may be Dalton if not Jesse James and I think a few of you have now picked up on it. A few of the other suspects have come in to defend themselves which is good, at least it is narrowing down the search.
laughin man
18-04-2011, 21:36
pZvhbkvZ-oY
Tonights write up at 10pm comes courtesy of (and with considerable gratitude, appreciation and thanks) Barn.
Its probably his finest work so far in terms of write ups.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 21:42
Tonights write up at 10pm comes courtesy of (and with considerable gratitude, appreciation and thanks) Barn.
Its probably his finest work so far in terms of write ups.
well go on then, why wait till 10?
Because you are the cattle in my paddock.
I've got a schedule and I'm sticking to it to cowboy.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 21:52
such a control freak!!
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_jmEeVR2KRls/TQyVqQ3UXII/AAAAAAAABVw/aiBb_ocJRb8/s1600/jealous.jpg
chelsea11
18-04-2011, 21:55
Am I still in this or what? I've been sort of panning over it seeing if it would get interesting, and it has (playing Red Dead again helped as well).
Don't know if it will be of any use but when I was on my own last time I played for the town, genuinely trying to suss out the 'bad' guys. Don't know if that's how Jesse James is doing it but its worth noting. You may think they are a Townie.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 21:55
:laugh: unlucky, you're dead!!
Am I still in this or what? I've been sort of panning over it seeing if it would get interesting, and it has (playing Red Dead again helped as well).
Don't know if it will be of any use but when I was on my own last time I played for the town, genuinely trying to suss out the 'bad' guys. Don't know if that's how Jesse James is doing it but its worth noting. You may think they are a Townie.
Sorry mate, I wrote you out. I gave it a couple of days but when you didn't post I assumed you still wanted out :(
chelsea11
18-04-2011, 21:58
Sorry mate, I wrote you out. I gave it a couple of days but when you didn't post I assumed you still wanted out :(
Ah no worries. Was to be expected.
With Thanks to Barn.
Here you go. Tell them to play this while reading for added effect:
wDl4OhRN3bQ
Hunter helped the stranger into the chair in front of the fire, and wrapped him in some old rags. He removed the boiling pot from the hearth and snuck a peak out of the window before extinguishing his candle lantern. He poured some broth into three bowls; two for Dale and the whore blowing him, and one for the mysterious fellow who had almost fallen victim to the bitterly cold night.
‘Thank you kindly mister’, he uttered as he gladly received the offering. ‘I’d surely to God have frozen to death if you didn’t come across me when you did.’
Hunter continued to pace the room as the man spoke, his paranoia obvious as he nervously propped a chair against the door.
‘Happy to oblige sir. What in tarnation were you doing alone out in these parts - if you don’t mind my asking?’
The stranger slurped the broth greedily before rubbing his hands feverishly to ward off the cold.
‘I will tell you good sir if you lend me your ears. Some days ago I was takin’ the train down to Austin. We was passin’ thru a few miles south of here when the driver came to a halt. I thought we was stoppin’ for water but soon I heard some commotion up front, folk screamin’ and such. Now I ain’t the sharpest tool in the shed but even I knew this was bandit country. Anyhow, one of them came aboard, forcin’ us off the train and roundin’ us up like cattle next to the tracks. Bastards took everythin’ I had. Problem was, they ain’t reckoned upon the two Pinkertons ridin’ the back of the train! Shots fired and all hell broke loose! Damn near crapped my pants I was so scared! I ran straight into the woods and kept runnin’. One of the bastards followed. He caught me with a shot to the ear and I done tripped along the slope of the river. My head hit a rock and thought I was a goner. The bastard appeared at the top of the ridge and smiled as he cocked his weapon. Yet God must have been smilin’ on me that day. I closed my eyes, ready to go to the Lord, when I heard a yell, and a shot rang out. Next thing I knew the damn cocksucker was lying on top of me, his eye blown right out! For a minute I thought I was in Hell, but the Lord had seen fit to spare me! I was alive, but the poor bastard was as dead as a doornail! I managed to push the poor wretch into the water, waited until night and tried to get out of there. I just walked and walked until my legs couldn’t carry me any further. That’s the last thing I remember until you came across me in the snow. That’s twice the good Lord has spared my hide – I must be blessed!’
Hunter sat down and rested his hat on his chest. ‘That’s some tall tale mister. Must have been the Cuntsboro Creek boys held you up, they been runnin’ this area for some time now. They led by Virgil BarnDoor as I recall. A bunch of bloodthirsty outcasts and immigrants, real scum. The worst was that lackey of his, real crazy no good son-of-a- bitch redneck who fronted a branch of the Klan for a while. Damn bastard was responsible for a number of my brothers being lynched; good thing I tracked down some of his fellow Klansmen and enacting retribution upon them. Christ what was his name? You recall Dale?’
Dale, cavorting with his whore, paid no attention to his friend. Hunter angrily kicked Dale’s chair.
‘What the hell?’
‘Virgil BarnDoor’s second in the Cuntsboro Creek posse – what’s his name?’
‘I can’t....wait a minute....Cornelius....Corneli us Johnson.’
‘Finally you’re good for something! Cornelius Johnson, damn what a firebrand. Jonno they call him.’
The stranger perked up.
‘Jonno! That’s the shout I heard – that must have been the poor sucker chasing me through the god-damn woods! A toast to the poor bastard!’
‘You sure? Johnson dead? Christ almighty I’ll never believe it. Guy killed more people than Sherman. Who’d have the balls to kill that no-good bastard?’
‘I just remembered something else. There could have been a second shout. I can’t be sure, but I think Jonno may have said something before the bullet took him. What was it now? Gat....Gant....Grat...’
Hunter lurched violently forward and grabbed the stranger.
‘Do you say Grat? Did Jonno shout “Grat”?’
‘I don’t know, partner! Please don’t hurt me, I never dun nothin’!’
‘GODDAMNIT DID HE SAY GRAT OR NOT?!?’
‘Please mister I can’t remember! He said summat like that, I can’t be sure tho! Why you so scared anyway?’
Hunter shot up to gaze through the window once more. He thought he heard something, but with the snow really coming down he could make out little in the darkness. It might have been a deer shooting past. It might have been nothing. The fire was slowly dying. All the while, Dale was impervious to the changing mood, getting head off his whore in the corner. Hunter placed his colt on the table and sat back down.
‘Grat Dalton and his two brothers have been on my back for weeks now over some bullshit. If it was him, as you say, then the son-of-a-bitch is close.’
‘The Dalton Gang? I heard of them boys. Grat, Bob and.....’
‘Emmett. The litter of the runt. I ain’t losin’ sleep over him. It’s his older brothers I’m worried about.’
The stranger chuckled.
‘Maybe that’s where you went wrong boy.’
The pair met each other’s gaze, before both quickly glanced the colt on the table. In a flash the stranger removed a concealed dagger and dived at Hunter, sending him backwards over the chair. Almost simultaneously the door crashed down to reveal two cloaked figures. The taller man glanced his shotgun towards the corner and shot, blowing off the whore’s head and taking Dale’s manhood in the process. He lay in a bloody mess on the floor screaming while Hunter engaged in a desperate struggle with the stranger. Eventually he was overwhelmed by the three men and pinned to the floor.
‘We got you boy. What a fool. Did you really think could escape the wrath of the Dalton gang?’
Emmett laughed hysterically. ‘We suckered you good boy!’
‘That’s some good work Em. You two drag him out front.’
‘What about him?’, Bob inquired, gesturing to the emasculated gent in the corner.
‘Let him bleed out.’
The three brothers threw Hunter to the snowy ground. He got up to run but was unaware that the trio had set bear traps, one of which shattered the helpless man’s ankle. As he fell to the ground his head hit another and it snapped around him, crushing his upper sternum. Blood was coughed forth, but the brothers were unwilling to allow him to die slowly. Ropes were tied to Hunter’s wrists and ankles, and then tied to individual horses. The horses trotted outward slowly, tightening the ropes and lifting Hunter slowly into the air. Gradually the sound of bones cracking and moans of agony filled the crisp night air. After allowing this to go on for a solid 15 minutes, the brothers smacked the hides of the horses, causing them to bolt hard. Hunter’s limbs were instantly ripped from his body. The white ground turned red. His wounds were mortal but the Daltons sought to make sure. Hunter’s limbless torso was strapped to a horse, affixed with dynamite, and launched over the nearby ravine, where horse and cargo exploded in mid-air. Grat lit a cigar and reared his horse before riding off into the night, flanked by his younger siblings.
Conclusion:
Hunter was Jesse James the Outlaw.
Hunter's Role details:
Jesse James
Hunter You are an independent 3rd party Bandit.
Abilites
- Loaded Deck You can choose to kill one person over the duration of the game at anytime of the game whether it is day or night who you suspect to be a rival bandit. In addition to this you can choose to frame another player for the death. The Texans will be told that a player has been killed and that the perpetrator has been arrested and jailed pending execution. The Town then has the choice of killing the framed player of saving him in the next day session. They cannot lynch or even vote for anyone else during this series of events.
- Good odds, You are an unrivalled gun slinger, on an ‘odd’ numbered night you cannot be killed by night active players.
- Texas Hold ‘Em, On the 3rd & 5th days (providing you are alive) you rob stagecoaches bringing money & liquor into town. The town is now unable to vote on these days as they are too poor to meet in the saloon.
Day 5 Begins:
Phatmann
18-04-2011, 22:09
Well a good night for the town I guess as we've found Jesse James and not lost one of our own. Leaves me a little confused as to Dragonflys position now though.
laughin man
18-04-2011, 22:10
That was brilliant Barndoor I really enjoyed it. The music just kicked in when Hunter got stabbed... brilliant ;)
Hunter you sneaky bastard leading the charge against Dragonfly with your sig bullshit!
Good result for the town :).
EDIT: I would like to state that this doesn't change my position on Dragonfly though as I believe him to be a Dalton.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 22:11
Is Dale dead or just dickless?
Dragonfly has to still be the main suspect, due to Appswah's voting
What a story. I said at the time when Hunter pointed out Dragonfly's sig it seemed similar to what Bammers did with fick's surprise. Sneaky son' bitch.
With Thanks to Barn.
Conclusion:
Hunter was Jesse James the Outlaw.
Hunter's Role details:
Jesse James
Hunter You are an independent 3rd party Bandit.
Abilites
- Loaded Deck You can choose to kill one person over the duration of the game at anytime of the game whether it is day or night who you suspect to be a rival bandit. In addition to this you can choose to frame another player for the death. The Texans will be told that a player has been killed and that the perpetrator has been arrested and jailed pending execution. The Town then has the choice of killing the framed player of saving him in the next day session. They cannot lynch or even vote for anyone else during this series of events.
- Good odds, You are an unrivalled gun slinger, on an ‘odd’ numbered night you cannot be killed by night active players.
- Texas Hold ‘Em, On the 3rd & 5th days (providing you are alive) you rob stagecoaches bringing money & liquor into town. The town is now unable to vote on these days as they are too poor to meet in the saloon.
Day 5 Begins:
Great write up. Nice song too :)
Well..... that's a shocker! Hunter, you crafty bastard!! I truly believed you were on our side.
However. Looks like the Daltons did us a HUGE favour. If they hadn't have lynched Jesse, we would have had another voteless day tomorrow. This is a great result. I can imagine that the Daltons are facpalming as we speak :D
Dale is undergoing reconstructive surgery on his chap :)
Bammers05
18-04-2011, 22:14
Good write-up, Barn.
That pretty much confirms to me that Dragonfly is a Dalton. I think if he was a Texan, it would have been a master-stroke by the Dalton's to get rid of him, but they didn't - they chose Hunter instead. Therefore, I'm pretty much ready to vote for Dragonfly now, although I'd obviously like to hear what everyone else thinks before doing so.
Billy Minof
18-04-2011, 22:15
Hunter you sneaky bastard leading the charge against Dragonfly with your sig bullshit!
Good result for the town :).
EDIT: I would like to state that this doesn't change my position on Dragonfly though as I believe him to be a Dalton.
Agreed, as I stated in my previous posts....as for Hunter, you sneaky son of gun...and I was only wondering to myself today if DF was Dalton then who could be JJ and one name stuck and it was yours but it felt like a long shot, what got me thinking it was you was that you are the one that spotted DFs sig and maybe it was you looking for images of JJ that led you to see that DFs sig was that of JJ....you sneaky, sneaky.....
Great read Barn......Hats off Gents to the man.....
What about poor old Dale, I feel more sorry for him than I would of Hunter even if Hunter was Texan, his poor small balls. :laugh:
Phatmann
18-04-2011, 22:17
Good write-up, Barn.
That pretty much confirms to me that Dragonfly is a Dalton. I think if he was a Texan, it would have been a master-stroke by the Dalton's to get rid of him, but they didn't - they chose Hunter instead. Therefore, I'm pretty much ready to vote for Dragonfly now, although I'd obviously like to hear what everyone else thinks before doing so.
The best thing to do would be to hear what Dragonfly has to say for himself but unfortunately he's been surprisingly absent considering the circumstances he's currently in.
Bammers05
18-04-2011, 22:20
The best thing to do would be to hear what Dragonfly has to say for himself but unfortunately he's been surprisingly absent considering the circumstances he's currently in.
Indeed, it would.
What are your thoughts on Dragonfly, Phatmann?
Wow! Jesse James had some great abilities there.
Hunter played quite a good game. Used a good reason on why DF could have been Jesse James. Making himself look like a hero in the process :lol:
Things we have to consider:
On Night 3, the Dalton's did not, or were not allowed to kill anyone. Is this because they went after Hunter who was safe on odd numbered nights? Or is it because they were roleblocked?
If they did try to kill Hunter, was their plan to pin the evidence on Dragonfly? Thus meaning he may not be a Dalton?
I'm still leaning towards him being a Dalton due to the Apps situation, but this has definitely threw a spanner in the works.
I also find it very ususual that fick is not posting.
laughin man
18-04-2011, 22:23
I havent really been paying attention to whats going on round here the last few pages is all I'v read, got the call to action last night so im just gonna go with the dragonfly vote for now but as I said id like to lynch Ali.... *spits on the ground*
Billy Minof
18-04-2011, 22:23
Well lads, a great nights work from the Daltons. lol.
I have to go now, watching the stars, ill check in, in the morning once Im out grazing the Buffalo, ill also have to cast my vote earlish enough tomorrow as I wont be here tomorrow night. I think I know where my vote is going to be cast though although alot can happen during the daytime.
*spits into the air, wind takes it back into my face*
laughin man
18-04-2011, 22:25
:smug:
Phatmann
18-04-2011, 22:27
Indeed, it would.
What are your thoughts on Dragonfly, Phatmann?
I thought the initial Jesse James idea was a bit weak but with Appswah following Dragonflys vote rather than voting for him, the suspicion of him being a Dalton looks strong. Would Appswah be stupid enough to stitch up his own mafia buddy though? or maybe he really did believe Matt was more suspicious than Dragonfly? My instincts would say that Appswah is stupid enough and his suspicion of Matt was rather weakly put across.
Wow! Jesse James had some great abilities there.
Hunter played quite a good game. Used a good reason on why DF could have been Jesse James. Making himself look like a hero in the process :lol:
Things we have to consider:
On Night 3, the Dalton's did not, or were not allowed to kill anyone. Is this because they went after Hunter who was safe on odd numbered nights? Or is it because they were roleblocked?
If they did try to kill Hunter, was their plan to pin the evidence on Dragonfly? Thus meaning he may not be a Dalton?
I'm still leaning towards him being a Dalton due to the Apps situation, but this has definitely threw a spanner in the works.
I also find it very ususual that fick is not posting.
Some good points there. Something to consider. You guys seemed to decide on Apps pretty late last night. So it may well be that a better candidate for lynching comes up.
I havent really been paying attention to whats going on round here the last few pages is all I'v read, got the call to action last night so im just gonna go with the dragonfly vote for now but as I said id like to lynch Ali.... *spits on the ground*
Because of my avatar? :ohmy:
Wow! Jesse James had some great abilities there.
Thanks :)
Was an enjoyable role to create.
Yeah, very imaginative Sminky. Well done.
Also, why the hell was Dale with Jesse James?
Coincidence mate, I gave Barn creative license.
Coincidence mate, I gave Barn creative license.
Oh cool. Just needed that cleared up.
http://thecia.com.au/reviews/a/images/assassination-of-jesse-james-by-the-coward-robert-ford-4.jpg
laughin man
18-04-2011, 22:34
Because of my avatar? :ohmy:
This towns no place for a ladie :mellow:
http://www.dvdbeaver.com/film2/DVDReviews45/good%20the%20bad%20and%20the%2 0ugly%20blu-ray/large/large%20good%20bad%20ugly%20bl u-ray1.jpg
http://thecia.com.au/reviews/a/images/assassination-of-jesse-james-by-the-coward-robert-ford-4.jpg
You know where you can stick your harmonica too.
Joel's point about the Daltons killing Hunter to try frame Dragonfly has got me thinking. Still hard to disregard him though.
laughin man
18-04-2011, 22:45
You know where you can stick your harmonica too.
Joel's point about the Daltons killing Hunter to try frame Dragonfly has got me thinking. Still hard to disregard him though.
Well I dont trust Joel so dont think too much of it ;)
Well I dont trust Joel so dont think too much of it ;)
Any reason why?
laughin man
18-04-2011, 22:49
Any reason why?
You'l find out when I decide to tell you... punk *spits on your feet*
*Looks down*
I always had you down as a guy who swallows.
I look forward to your reasons.
BarnDoor
18-04-2011, 22:51
Dale can come back as the eunuch of the Old West.
Bammers05
18-04-2011, 22:52
You'l find out when I decide to tell you... punk *spits on your feet*
I'd like to know why too. There's no point in accusing someone of being a Dalton, if you're not gonna back up that accusation with a reason.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 22:55
*Looks down*
I always had you down as a guy who swallows.
I look forward to your reasons.
:laugh:
I'd like to know why too. There's no point in accusing someone of being a Dalton, if you're not gonna back up that accusation with a reason.
He said he doesn't trust him, didn't say he was daltons, yet
There still could be a cult, we would only know of thier existence when one dies wouldnt we?
laughin man
18-04-2011, 22:55
I'd like to know why too. There's no point in accusing someone of being a Dalton, if you're not gonna back up that accusation with a reason.
I still have afew hours before I get my rope *drinks water*
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 22:57
I still have afew hours before I get my rope *drinks water*
dry mouth from all that spitting :laugh:
Bammers05
18-04-2011, 22:59
:laugh:
He said he doesn't trust him, didn't say he was daltons, yet
There still could be a cult, we would only know of thier existence when one dies wouldnt we?
Regardless of whether he thinks he's Dalton or just doesn't trust him, I'd like to know the reason why.
And yes, there could be a cult. And yes we would only know of their existence if one of them died. Don't really see what that has to do with what I said though.
smudger2008
18-04-2011, 23:02
Regardless of whether he thinks he's Dalton or just doesn't trust him, I'd like to know the reason why.
And yes, there could be a cult. And yes we would only know of their existence if one of them died. Don't really see what that has to do with what I said though.
You said you don't understand why LM would accuse Joel of being daltons without reasons and I simply told you he didn't accuse him of being daltons.
vBulletin® v3.8.2, Copyright ©2000-2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.