Played FIFA 09 and PES 09.
There is no words to describe the game play of PES.
Its just so much superior to FIFA's.
FIFA tries to be too realistic and fails completely. The flow is just not there. I dont know whats the deal with the fan sounds, when you score they go loud and wild, but as soon as the play starts again at the center, they just go silent again instantly, just weird.
PES on the other hand tries to be realistic but at the same time it is also arcade like, which makes it a more funner experience.
I do think FIFA 09 is not a bad game because of the above things. If i never tried PES i wouldve probably been happy with FIFA. Although, i still think PES 6 is even better than FIFA 09.
I give PES 09 a 10
I give PES 6 a 10 still!
and FIFA 09 an 8