Got PES2012 first week it came out and was really excited based on the DEMO. Right away the game seemed off, but the patches brought hope which has left.
I play on the PS3, mainly BAL mode.
I agree with the majority in this thread that 2011 was fun, even with the faults, and 2012 is a labor of love. I really want to like this game but a few things just keep killing it for me.
1. Computer taking over your player. This should never happen period! Good example of this occured last night. Ball was cleared down the field, AI took control of my player, AMF, and he started to sprint after the ball. Ran 50 yards only to see my CB get to the ball. Also when the ball is put into the box, I love the way your entire time sprints after the ball and no one seems to play their position. I know you can use super cancel, but you shouldn't have to! I don't recall this happening in 2011. Not to the degree it does in 2012. :realmad:
2. Player getting stuck to opposing players. At first I liked the way your player reacted when running into players/official. After the patches that interaction now seems flawed. Now it seems like you get stuck like glue when you run into a player. Yes I know players grab, but not 100% of the time.
3. Shooting/passing/power. Just seems hit or miss. I know player position, touch, timing, play a part but it seems like it has a mind of it's own. Plus too many players seem to shoot/pass with no power/ball floats.
4. Agree with techboy that the game is set to go forward 100% of the time. No build up play.
5. Stamina. I'm in my 5th season in BAL, started with 61 stamina and I'm now at 73. I've had training points maxed and also down to 2. No matter how many points, it doesn't seem to grow any faster. My player is now 22 and I've been a starter since my 2nd season. The more you play/train, stamina should grow faster than it does. Don't feel it's realistic at all.
I want to like this game, but I'm not having fun like I did with 2011. Whatever Konami did from the DEMO to actual release is beyond me. Quit trying to be like FIFA and go back to BUILT FOR FREEDOM.
My .02.