I reckon 2008 is best because of the commentary and closer matched online play.I bought 1,2,3,4,5,6 for PS2 and liked them all but 2008 on my Xbox is my favourite of them all. The players faces are very good in the editing part. 5 and 6 was good for editing though like untucked shirts but I ain't that bothered anymore. 1 was good because players like Romario and Batistuta were in it 2 was ok, I enjoyed playing 3 the most because of the new graphics and skill moves but as I said I reckon the new one is the best.