Note: Fanboys will become allergic if they post in this thread and possible die, you been warned.
I have now got Fifa 09 and I have just played the demo of pro evo and here is what I think so far.
Basically starting with the Fifa 09 game, I played it, brilliant gameplay but not very good graphics. See last year I had pes2008 and the audience was pretty realistic, 3Dish, in Fifa 09, from the audience front to back, its thin as paper.......HUH? Im worried that a strong wind will come and blow them all away and ruin the match.
Secondly the game faces in Fifa 09, like someone painted on the faces because the expressions do not change at all, even when they score, pretty dumb to be honest. Then I started reading all the comments on the pes 2009 demo, and think uh oh did I buy the wrong game.
Played the demo....I was really unimpressed, The moving capabilities is completely messed up, and the audience........***** that pes2008.... WHAT!? They dumber stuff down as well!!!!
Now I know a lot of you say, its gameplay first then graphics....well dont we want that full football experience, and with gameplay you need good graphics otherwise it can be slightly disappointing, deep down most of you know that.
Movement of player - Fifa wins by a margin.
AI reactions and movement - Im thinking Fifa wins but tbh I have not played much of the PES demo.
Graphics of Audience - Both really disappointing but pro evo wins.
Graphics of player - Pro evo wins but I wasnt unimpressed by both.
Football atmosphere - Fifa wins in my opinion, thing is you need those little extra bits like guard standing about and it just felt Fifa was better.
The Pitch Graphics and size - Undecided, both pretty good though.
Tips for both:
Audience:
Pro evo, if you going to use flags, make it realistic!
Fifa, come join the 3 dimension!
Plus both please make the graphics look smoother.
Gameplay:
Pro evo, dont restrict movement
Fifa, improve goalkeepers reaction so they can go for the ball before the players and avoid danger.
Football Atmosphere:
Both, have guards and technicians that actually move now and again, it will work wonders and try do a lot of audience profiles because they can easily be distinguished and make them 3d.
Billboards:
Pro evo, get any sponsors, any at all, having only a konami billboard nearly all the time, quite stupid tbh but did like the animation of them.
Tbh I think Konami and EA should both hang their heads in shame, this is next gen consoles, make us some next gen games if you can!
For the pro evo buyers, Im hoping that the demo is like a rough version of it because end of the day, we all just customers who want our money worth and why should I laugh if you made a poor purchase, its down right uncalled for!
But far IMO, fifa demo was better and Im glad I brought the game because the gameplay is fantastic.
*Puts flamesuit on just incase*
Your thoughts?
I have now got Fifa 09 and I have just played the demo of pro evo and here is what I think so far.
Basically starting with the Fifa 09 game, I played it, brilliant gameplay but not very good graphics. See last year I had pes2008 and the audience was pretty realistic, 3Dish, in Fifa 09, from the audience front to back, its thin as paper.......HUH? Im worried that a strong wind will come and blow them all away and ruin the match.
Secondly the game faces in Fifa 09, like someone painted on the faces because the expressions do not change at all, even when they score, pretty dumb to be honest. Then I started reading all the comments on the pes 2009 demo, and think uh oh did I buy the wrong game.
Played the demo....I was really unimpressed, The moving capabilities is completely messed up, and the audience........***** that pes2008.... WHAT!? They dumber stuff down as well!!!!
Now I know a lot of you say, its gameplay first then graphics....well dont we want that full football experience, and with gameplay you need good graphics otherwise it can be slightly disappointing, deep down most of you know that.
Movement of player - Fifa wins by a margin.
AI reactions and movement - Im thinking Fifa wins but tbh I have not played much of the PES demo.
Graphics of Audience - Both really disappointing but pro evo wins.
Graphics of player - Pro evo wins but I wasnt unimpressed by both.
Football atmosphere - Fifa wins in my opinion, thing is you need those little extra bits like guard standing about and it just felt Fifa was better.
The Pitch Graphics and size - Undecided, both pretty good though.
Tips for both:
Audience:
Pro evo, if you going to use flags, make it realistic!
Fifa, come join the 3 dimension!
Plus both please make the graphics look smoother.
Gameplay:
Pro evo, dont restrict movement
Fifa, improve goalkeepers reaction so they can go for the ball before the players and avoid danger.
Football Atmosphere:
Both, have guards and technicians that actually move now and again, it will work wonders and try do a lot of audience profiles because they can easily be distinguished and make them 3d.
Billboards:
Pro evo, get any sponsors, any at all, having only a konami billboard nearly all the time, quite stupid tbh but did like the animation of them.
Tbh I think Konami and EA should both hang their heads in shame, this is next gen consoles, make us some next gen games if you can!
For the pro evo buyers, Im hoping that the demo is like a rough version of it because end of the day, we all just customers who want our money worth and why should I laugh if you made a poor purchase, its down right uncalled for!
But far IMO, fifa demo was better and Im glad I brought the game because the gameplay is fantastic.
*Puts flamesuit on just incase*
Your thoughts?
