Which players do you think their overall should be?

[Raykion]

http://www.pesdb.net/pes2012/

So yeah, tittle.


I think Coentrão deserves 88~90, Nolito 81, Pato 90, Nani 92, (he is so underrated in this game, 85 really? He's been the best player in the field time and time again in MU games), Meireles 87. I'll post a few more later.



For a second note, I'm really happy that the 3 Portuguese teams finally get their well-deserved boost, and due respect, they barely had players above 80, now they have Hulk 82, Gaitán 84, Moutinho 82, Garay 80, Emerson 80, Rui Patricio 84, João Pereira 82, etc; etc;.




Edit: Villa 82? What the hell, Konami?




Anyway, what are your opinions?

 

[Ali]

Obviously you're a bit biased towards the Portuguese players, fair enough. But Coentrao doesn't deserve a stat that high. He's good.... but not THAT good. 85 is good enough for Nani.

Remember, this isn't Fifa, overalls are generally lower on PES. 85 for example is a great rating. Also remember that players such as Nani are given lower ratings to give them more realistic growth in ML.

 

[metsuri69]

word Ali, about the ML growth. That's what's a big factor in Konami stats.

And ppl should stop staring the "Overall rating". What's more important is the key stats of the player and do they reflect reality.

 

[StringerBell]

Agreed and lets not forget player cards. I'll take a lower overall any day if the guy has cards he's more valuable.

 

[techboy11]

Totally agree. Defoe is rated at 60 odd I believe, I may be wrong, but he's a scoring machine for me. His key attributes are his quick feet movement and lightning response.

OVR means nothing I believe, it's a guide along with the A-E ratings. This year be clear what you want - if you want a solid DMF, look at his cards for enforcer etc and check this his resistance is good for example. I'd pay little attention to overalls.

 

[MysteryMan]

Players deserve a much lower stat than in PES games, infact Messi should probably be around 90~.

 

[Cristiano92]

Noone cares about overall Rating.

 

[muscularmatt]

Noone cares about overall Rating.

Correction - noone with a brain cares about it. There are plenty of morons that don't realise it's generated by a pointless, subjective mathematical formula.

THE OVERALL RATING DEPENDS ON HOW IMPORTANT KONAMI HAS DECIDED CERTAIN ATTRIBUTES ARE.

If you're too lazy to spend a few seconds looking at them yourself and making your own decision, then you don't have a very good football brain.