I have been playing the 360 and PC versions for a few days now and there are many contrasting factors. I would go as far as to say the games are not comparable. They are totally different engines.
Here are the differences that I can see, you may agree or disagree with some of this:
1. The look of the graphics are not comparable. The 360 pitch seems larger, the crowds are animated better, the pitch looks better and the animations are more enhanced.
2. The 360 version has a smarter AI. THe game is easier on PC.
3. The PC version is an updated PES5, while the 360 is a totally new engine.
4. The PC has many extras in regards to managing the teams, editing and saving of replays while the 360 version lacks in all of these.
5. The player animations in terms of the way they run shoot and pass are very different between PC and 360, with 360 taking the cake. Although the animation of goal net is better on the PC.
6. Shooting and passing on 360 is more precise and yet more difficult if you are not a previous player of PES. The PC version is similar to PES5. In fact shootng and passing on PC seems easier than PES5. The shooting on 360 is sometimes a little more wayward, and the goals are not as spectacular as those you can score on the PC, like outside shots that curl past the keeper.
7. THe goal keeper is much smarter in 360 version compared to the PC.
8. The game response in terms of switching players, shooting and passing is better on teh PC compared to 360. Very slight difference but I feel it is contrasted when you are a veteran of the game.
9. The PC version is still not in true wide mode, and thus the windowed version is preferable on wide screen LCDs.
10. With the 360 version it doesnt seem to matter too much if a player with a rating of say ninety is against one with 80, for example running, they seem about the same, you can only tell the difference if there is a significant difference in attribute. And same with shooting, I used a player with 65 for accuracy and had same success as one with 90. In the PC version its easily contrasted.
And there are many many other superficial differences. For those of you whom have experiences both versions, what do you think?:unsure:
Here are the differences that I can see, you may agree or disagree with some of this:
1. The look of the graphics are not comparable. The 360 pitch seems larger, the crowds are animated better, the pitch looks better and the animations are more enhanced.
2. The 360 version has a smarter AI. THe game is easier on PC.
3. The PC version is an updated PES5, while the 360 is a totally new engine.
4. The PC has many extras in regards to managing the teams, editing and saving of replays while the 360 version lacks in all of these.
5. The player animations in terms of the way they run shoot and pass are very different between PC and 360, with 360 taking the cake. Although the animation of goal net is better on the PC.
6. Shooting and passing on 360 is more precise and yet more difficult if you are not a previous player of PES. The PC version is similar to PES5. In fact shootng and passing on PC seems easier than PES5. The shooting on 360 is sometimes a little more wayward, and the goals are not as spectacular as those you can score on the PC, like outside shots that curl past the keeper.
7. THe goal keeper is much smarter in 360 version compared to the PC.
8. The game response in terms of switching players, shooting and passing is better on teh PC compared to 360. Very slight difference but I feel it is contrasted when you are a veteran of the game.
9. The PC version is still not in true wide mode, and thus the windowed version is preferable on wide screen LCDs.
10. With the 360 version it doesnt seem to matter too much if a player with a rating of say ninety is against one with 80, for example running, they seem about the same, you can only tell the difference if there is a significant difference in attribute. And same with shooting, I used a player with 65 for accuracy and had same success as one with 90. In the PC version its easily contrasted.
And there are many many other superficial differences. For those of you whom have experiences both versions, what do you think?:unsure: