the thing is though guys. See all the great iss/pro games, im not doubting they were excellent ( for the time ), but if you were to go and play it like it was brand new, im pretty sure you would get bored after a few days. I think each PES has just got better and better ( yes, including 08 AFTER the lag was sorted). Im not voting because i think 09 will be the best because it has a year's worth of gameplay whereas the older ones don't. They have the Legendary Status because at the time, they were mind blowingly good
Proper classic games that will NEVER age are games like Goldeneye for N64, Resident Evil for the PS and Counter-Strike 1.6 for the PC