If you bought Fifa 09 and played it for a couple of months then you'd realise EA have got the gameplay right. Just like Pro Evo always has, Fifa takes time to really get into. I haven't played Fifa since 98, and have been playing PES/ISS for 15 years since the very first one on the SNES. Add to this, i probably had a 90% win record against a large circle of friends (and their friends), so i'm a decent player. Because of my complete allegance to PES, and because i was so used to the Pro Evo style, when i first played the Fifa 09 demo I thought it was shit. From there i downloaded the PES demo and just played that, thinking it was far superior to Fifa still.
After a couple of weeks of playing the PES demo and semi-enjoying it (not as much as the old ones on the PS2 though), Fifa got released and the prospect of 10v10 online and the various other online features made me think i'll give it a go. Since that day i haven't looked back. I still bought Pro Evo and put some time into it, hoping that it would grow on me and prove itself to still be the king, but it just hasn't happened. I still now slam it in about once a week hoping that it'll suddenly rediscover the old PES magic, but each time after 1-2 games i just think "Shit the bed, Fifa is SO SO SO SO SO SO much better now."
The graphics are better, the passing is better, the AI is better in the way that if you actually watch off the ball movement by the attacking and defending side, it all makes sense. Pro Evo is full of manic runs, with no logic behind the player's movements.
The manual passing, shooting, crossing etc. are great in Fifa too, give it an added depth and something else to master. I especially enjoy manual crosses, as they allow you to pick out players outside the box for volleys etc. Quality.
I'm also bcoming a bigger fan of the dribbling and trick sticks. For a month and a half i couldn't take anyone on. It's still kind of difficult now, but i'm making clear improvements, and on the hardest difficulty setting i can now use a couple of tricks effectively and actually take players on without the tricks as well. This is very very hard and requires a lot more precision than PES, but is so rewarding.
Now don't get me wrong, Fifa still has flaws that are frustrating, and i haven't written this to completely kiss it's ass. The responsiveness is still a little slow at times, although the more you play it the more responsive it feels. The cut scenes for goal celebrations etc. pre-programmed and not in-game graphics, which sucks. Eg. the CPU scores a late goal to cut your lead to 2-1, the player runs off to the crowd to celebrate, then it cuts to them fishing the ball out the back of the net to get it back to the half way line. And finally, the ball hits the woodwork too much!!! I can live with these faults though, because overall it offers a much closer representation of real football, and a more varied game, than any other football title ever released.