Hmm I might get laughed at for saying this but I'll have to say
Anelka.
I'm french and I know this guy since '96 and his failed career reflected bad on his stats unfortunately.. As you know a lot of players are overrated because they play in a great club but they ain't that great.
I'm sure Anelka would have better stats and recognition if he had been better advised and if he had made the right choices. He would probably be a much better player too now.
I'm not saying he should be at the top in PES I'm saying the current stats doesn't reflect his strengths which are :
- First touch. I've read on pes stats database that they're amazed about Benzema's first touch but Anelka's is way better trust me..
- Acceleration/Speed. In Clairefontaine, where the french national team practices, they had a little sprinting contest recently. Results were 1)Anelka 2)Evra 3)Henry. Henry used to win all of these back in the days..
- Shoot Power. Low accuracy unfortunately but his shoot power should be a lot higher than Henry's
I repeat don't get me wrong I'm not saying he should be at the top. I'm just saying seeing him at the same level as players like Govou, sorry but no..