LOL @ OCKRASS - Hey, I'm no PES fanboy, by any stretch of the imagination, I have written extensive pieces on here, on evoweb, etc etc, highlighting the games flaws.
BUT
You can't be serious about FIFA? Even die hard Fifa-ites say it's a joke. I fall into this trap every now and again for my sins, I have a couple of 'bad' games on PES and think fk this I'll play FIFA for a bit - it usually takes around three minutes for me to realise what a train wreck this new FIFA is. It's ice hockey at it's best, the tackle radius is so large you could probably take the ball off someone in the six yard box from the halfway line. The goals are mundane, the players kind of float, you get the same endless boring AI attacks, no build up play just two passes from back to front, then either a cross, then a CPU headed goal.
"More realistic gameplay" - are you serious? Do you watch real football? Sometimes, I don't know if you've seen it on tele. but the opponents sometimes do something called "passing the ball back". FIFA dazzles on presentation, everything looks polished and stunning, you could take it for a game on the tv such is the detail to visuals (from afar mind you). But the gameplay is atrocious.
FIFA is miles away from being a representation of football as it's played in real life. Of course you can good at FIFA, I even won a few games on Legendary, that doesn't make the game any good, or me any good. All that shows is that if you have the patience of a nun, can play a full ninety minute match, press a combination of buttons in certain way, you can score a headed goal against a genetically modified super-human defence who can read your every moves, ten seconds before you can initiate anything. The game is appalling. Every player feels the same, you can pick a keeper up front and will score wonder goals, or Messi in defence and still do a job like Vidic. It's just fking shit.
I played FIFA World Cup, now that was a game, if they had tightened that up and made it harder I could see where you're coming from, but FIFA 2011, man where do you start.
Listen, each to their own, but PES resembles football, even with all it's bugs and glitches. PES out of the box, knocks FIFA for six. The CPU on FIFA always, ALWAYS goes forward, that's just not football. FIFA relies on the over-usage of pressure, both from the controlled player and the CPU team mate pressure button. I don't want everything automated just to make the game play okay and to get the CPU to pass the ball backwards once in a while.
Like I say, every time your bored of PES, think it's poor, having an off day, players feeling unresponsive just put FIFA in for a bit, and when Cameron Jerome scores three consecutive headers from silly laughable crosses against you, you'll calmly press eject, snap the fkin FIFA disc, and put PES back in.
The lesser of two evils - definitely.