PES vs FIFA rating(post your opinion)

[slamsoze]

I 'd like to compare some sections of these games.I play PES 3 and FIFA 2004 but PES 3 is better with difference!This year i havent played PES 4 yet (i 'll buy it next month)but i have played FIFA 2005 so i will compare these 3 games.

>better
=equal

GameplayES3>FIFA05>FIFA04

GraphicsES3>FIFA05=FIFA04

SoundES3=FIFA05=FIFA04

Edit modeES3>>>FIFA05 (no FIFA04 edit mode)

Custom Tournament:Konami Cup>>>FIFA05 custom tournament (no FIFA04 tournament)

Championships:Carrier mode 05 > Master League PES3 > carrier 04

Free kicks,corner kicksES3 >>>FIFA05=FIFA04



Post your ratings!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Giggsy11]

sound equal? LOL

 

[CtrlAltDel]

nice sig giggsy
oh and the second that this thread turns into a flame fest, its gone

 

[gmsubzero]

I have FIFA 2005. I can only compare it to Winning Eleven 7 international right now. BUT this still holds true I'm sure. (mind you this is only for ps2) THE only thing FIFA is better at then Winning Eleven 7 is its online play. (becuase winning eleven doesn't have it) But then again you get on there and its even slower then the game itself. its like the frame rate is cut in half. But everything is always scripted it seems like. The online tournaments are nice but again its killed by the gameplay. So winning eleven is a hundred times better. So blah

 

[rich725]

I have both games and i think PES 4 wipes the floor with Fifa. The only resaon why people the FIFA brand of games in the first palce is because they have own the rights and trademarks to most teams and comoptions. But Fifa game play is SHOCKING to say the least. So i am a big PES 4 Fan big it up to Konmami and long my the PSE seirs rule

 

[Arjen-Robben]

PES3 and PES4 compared to FIFA makes FIFA look like an amateur game made by 2 people...

 

[PheonoM]

too many things on FIFA are scripted which makes it feel like you dont really have much control, while in PES you decide (in big brother geordie style voice).

 

[hedache]

Out of 10, i'd say

Gameplay:
PES4 - 8 / FIFA05 - 4

Graphics:
PES4 - 6 / FIFA05 - 8

Sound:
PES4 - 3 / FIFA05 - 7

Editing:
PES4 - 7 / FIFA05 - 3

Career/Master League:
PES4 - 8 / FIFA05 - 5

AI:
PES4 - 7 / FIFA05 - 2

Freekicks:
PES4 - 7 / FIFA05 - 4

Corner Kicks:
PES4 - 8 / FIFA05 - 1

Konami: 5
EA: 1

Online:
PES4 - 3 / FIFA05 - 7

I like PES4 better even though I have to admit FIFA is better on some aspects. Not the important ones though.

 

[Arjen-Robben]

Gameplay:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 1

Graphics:
PES4 - 9 / FIFA05 - 2

Sound:
PES4 - 5 / FIFA05 - 9

Editing:
PES4 - 8 / FIFA05 - 1

Career/Master League:
PES4 - 2 / FIFA05 - 10

AI:
PES4 - 8 / FIFA05 - 9

Freekicks:
PES4 - 2 / FIFA05 - 9

Corner Kicks:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 4

Konami: 7
EA: 3

Online:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 1

 

[slamsoze]

Gameplay:
PES4 - 9 / FIFA05 - 3

Graphics:
PES4 - 6 / FIFA05 - 7

Sound:
PES4 - 4 / FIFA05 - 6

Editing:
PES4 - 8 / FIFA05 - 4

Career/Master League:
PES4 - 9 / FIFA05 - 5

AI:
PES4 - 9 / FIFA05 - 4

Freekicks:
PES4 - 7 / FIFA05 - 4

Corner Kicks:
PES4 - 7 / FIFA05 - 1

Konami: 7
EA: 3

Online:
PES4 - 4 / FIFA05 - 6

 

[Combo]

gameplay:
pes4 - 9 / fifa05 - 4

Graphics:
pes4 - 7 / fifa05 - 7

Sound:
pes4 - 5 / fifa05 - 8

Editing:
pes4 - 7 / fifa05 - 6

Career/Masterleague:
pes4 - 7 / fifa05 - 6

AI:
pes4 - 8 / fifa05 - 5

Freekicks:
pes4 - 7 / fifa05 - 4

cornerkicks:
pes4 - 7 / fifa05 - 2

Konami:7
EA:5

online:
pes4 - 4 / fifa05 - 7

 

[codename 47]

Gameplay:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 6
Graphics:
PES4 - 9 / FIFA05 - 8
Sound:
PES4 - 5 / FIFA05 - 9

Editing:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 4

Career/Master League:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - Haven't tried

AI:
PES4 - 8 / FIFA05 - 6

Freekicks:
PES4 - 9 / FIFA05 - 5 too easy to score freekicks

Corner Kicks:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 1 worst part of fifa

Konami: 9
EA: 1

Online:
Haven't been online

 

[Giggsy11]

nice sig giggsy
oh and the second that this thread turns into a flame fest, its gone

flame fest lol? your the tough man taking away my sig - get rid i don't care

Gameplay:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 7

Graphics:
PES4 - 8 / FIFA05 - 8

Sound:
PES4 - 4 / FIFA05 - 9

Editing:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 5

Career/Master League:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 7

AI:
PES4 - 9 / FIFA05 - 6

Freekicks:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 5

Corner Kicks:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 4

Konami: 6
EA: 8

Online:
PES4 - 7 / FIFA05 - 8

 

[Tenacious D]

Gameplay:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 5
Graphics:
PES4 - 9 / FIFA05 - 7 (what's up with their big heads)
Sound:
PES4 - 5 / FIFA05 - 9 (FIFA great commentray and back ground music)

Editing:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 4 (FIFA just decided to copy PES)

Career/Master League:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - (Haven't tried FIFA career mode)

AI:
PES4 - 8 / FIFA05 - 6

Freekicks:
PES4 - 9 / FIFA05 - 5 (too easy to score freekicks)

Corner Kicks:
PES4 - 10 / FIFA05 - 1 (dont understand them on FIFA)

Konami: 9 (This series along with The Metal Gear series are the best)
EA: 1 (I like some of their games but this one sucks compared to PES)

Online:
Haven't been online

 

[S3RB]

fifa is shit u cant do nothin in it exept play the game
u cant edit which is funn and u cant even create ur own team....
i give PES all of them 10-0