The Best "GTA Clone"?

[Haribo]

Ever since GTA 3 came out in 2001 there's been a lot of games that have had big influences from it (and it's sequels). But which of the so-called "GTA Clones" do you think is the best?

Note: Despite Driver being a '3D world' before GTA was, I still included it in the poll as it owes a lot to GTA with it's PS2 games. Also, I opted from including Canis Canem Edit as it's a Rockstar game.

 

[greenegg]

Wow cool thread very popular :ninja:

 

[Haribo]

I'm sure you're flabbergasted :ninja:

 

[greenegg]

I'm sure you're flabbergasted :ninja:

Don't worry if this thread hits rock bottom :ninja:

 

[Hansel]

True Crime, but pretty much all of the games in that list sucked a bit,.

 

[mufcsean]

When did you get Vet status, anyway, Scarface is my fave out of those

 

[Ryαп]

Agree with Poff about the games sucking, but Saints Row is the best of a bad bunch.

 

[Cali]

Scarface: The World Is Yours, Saints Row a close second.

 

[Eric Clyde]

The only ones I have played out of that list are The Getaway, True Crime: SoLA and NYC. However, I voted for other because I think Mafia was the best out of the lot. Mafia was a truely great game.

 

[Jonny2J]

Mafia shirley Andy?

 

[Haribo]

I considered Mafia to be completely different :/

 

[Dan]

All of 'em are decent for about 2 weeks, but after that, you realize how average they are.

GTA on the other hand, is pure magic for months and months.

 

[Eric Clyde]

All of 'em are decent for about 2 weeks, but after that, you realize how average they are.

GTA on the other hand, is pure magic for months and months.

I completed SA in 10 days and it sat on my shelf.

 

[Dan]

I like taking it slow, replaying missions and stuff.

The best on the list is probably Scarface, still not completed it and with Crackdown on the horizon, I probably never will.

 

[The Stig]

Only just noticed this and I know it has nothing to do with the thread topic but shouldn't Vet bars say something different instead of "Insight Veteran" as the site isn't named PESInsight anymore... :erm:

 

[Phatmann]

I voted for Simpsons Hit & Run :mellow:

I think the vet bars should stay as Insight Veteran.

 

[Jah]

Saints Row

 

[martin_cranie]

Also, I opted from including Canis Canem Edit as it's a Rockstar game.

Mistake - Bully is far better than any of the crap on the list. I realise there's common ground, but it's still a different game. I'm going for Driv3r as it was vaguely cool for a while.

 

[laughin man]

Mistake - Bully is far better than any of the crap on the list. I realise there's common ground, but it's still a different game. I'm going for Driv3r as it was vaguely cool for a while.

Check out scar face, its not a remake of the film it just continues his story

It does the character justice as well with an almost perfect voice, great game and i would recommend it to anyone, i played it for 2 weeks i think and im not really into games :happy:

 

[TheAlchemist]

The Getaway, hands down.