Risk / frustration button - Certain players can be given a star as to whether they will removing shirt, winding up oposition fans or jump into the crowd after scoring (eg Rooney would be given a wind up star) and abusing officials when penalised (Rooney would have and abuse official star) Their 'unsportsmanlike' celebration would be activated with the risk button (R3) if pressed in between the goal being scored and the celebration scene (or fouls being made and booking / freekick taking).
Last resort button (also R3) - This would be the same as the Risk button but used in open play. Stars for violence (kicking and elbowing), professional fouls (shirt pulling, tripping from behing or handballing depending on the context), and Diving would be available. (Totti could have a diving star, Terry a cynical challenge star, and Todd a violence star).
Dusk added to Day and Night option. The sky would start as daylight and progress to darkness by full time. This would apply in most English winter matches.
Sort out the fans and make them more realistic and emotive.
No classic players in the master league (such as Maradona)
Rivalrys - On club / national team editor there would be a section to choose up to 5 players that would be booed by the oposition fans. You could also select up to 5 rival teams where the atmosphere would be derby like and more tackles in the game.
Tatoos on player editor.
The chance to create national teams.
Tracksuit bottoms available for keepers.
Rolled up sleeves.
Set up set piece routines such as which players come up for corners and which stay back.
Eartape as an option.
Coloured gloves.
Choice of ankle socks over the football socks.
A choice of collar up/ down.
Editable goalie gloves.
3rd and Euro kits.
International squads of 32 players, which you narrow down to 23 on the team menu.
A vice captain and second choice for dead balls? (it's annoying when the opposition sub their captain or dead ball taker and the job goes to somebody completely innapropriate)
Autumn and Spring as seasons. There should be short sleeve weather, long sleeve weather AND glove weather.
Editable refs.
Stadium creator and editor.
Under 21 teams for England, Spain, France, Germany and Holland.
Editable managers on the touchline.
Ball editor & creator.
Better commentary and crowds (the excitement level of the fans should raise when the ball gets nearer to goal and for set pieces).
The option to edit the licenced teams.
All national teams
Full Portuguese, Greek, Turkish, Swedish, Russian, Belgian, Ukrainian, Danish and Scottish leagues.