The prefect trick stick would be one with loads of different skills, but intuative in that the directions you push the stick in resemble the actual ball/body movement that makes up the trick. I know they already do to some degree, but it could definitely be improved.
Agreed.. I've always wanted a Control for "Shielding" the ball, something intuitive.
Like by Holding or Tapping the L1 button + Directional Stick; the player shields the ball in that direction. Like if you press to the right, the player moves his body to the right, protecting the ball from the opponent on the right -whilst- at the same time exposing himself to whomever may be on the Left.
Which is like you said; "intuitive in that the directions you push the stick in resemble the actual ball/body movement".
It would open up "dribbling play" or "on-the-ball play". Because by exposing yourself to the opponent on your left, you could then continue your move by dribbling past the opponent on your left. Which is something that you can't really do in any PES version to date.
The problem with advances in the "dribbling" department is that, as a consequence the Defending would need to improve. More defensive animations, more defensive tactics, more defensive controls, more Defensive Stats, etc, etc..
And it isn't a problem really, because it's all beneficial. But knowing how lazy Konami are proving to be, they will only improve in one aspect, either offensive or defensive. "One step forwards, Two steps back" seems to be Konami's motto.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
And besides that, I think that the "Dribbling Stats" are highly outdated. Basically, in PES09 Cristiano Ronaldo and Leo Messi are BOTH equally good at "Cutting the Ball".. Which is very Unrealistic.
I mean, the Old "Dribbling Accuracy" and "Dribbling Speed" Stats.. Shouldn't that be divided into more Specific Stats such as "Step Overs", "360 Roulette", "Cutting The Ball", "Shielding The Ball", "Flicking The Ball" ??