Bring back handball rule

[Ultimate777]

This needs to be done, countless times playing 2010 there were occasions where you can see the player clearly handle the ball yet nothing is called. Its unrealistic because its essential rule in the game in real life. It may add to more whistle blowing causing interuption in play but still its rule is a vital component to the game in keeping it in check otherwise it would no longer be called football. You wouldnt take out offsides so why was the handball feature ever taken out when it was in the game back on the PS2. If its inconvenient for some gamers simply provide menu option to turn it off

Here are some youtube clicks showing what Im talking about in pes2010 that was overlooked because the rule is not implemented where the player gains clear advantage with the usage of his hand.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1K9FD-FnbX0

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXf8rDkDoFQ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9NO-E3X8Y28

 

[muscularmatt]

Yes I agree, but it's so hard to get right. A few games have tried it in the past but it's always ended up ruining the game. Maybe if they made it possible for you to deliberately handle the ball...

 

[The Dude]

good idea

 

[savic4430]

no why bother, Australia - Serbia 85. min handball, but no penalty for Serbia
meanwhile, Ghana - Serbia, handball, penalty for Ghana, Serbia - Germany, handball, penalty for Germany...

I am sorry for off-topic comment, but I am devastated by that referee call.

Ok. I agree. If it is manageable for implementing handball in game, it is ok. (Handball was on previous series, but only attackers handball play is whistled)

Other thing that bothers me is poor offside calls. (if I use super cancel to prevent my player to play the ball, why judges has to stop the game, calling the offside!?)
(also, that wasn't the case in earlier pes series (ok i meant on PES 5 again just lovinig that game )

 

[fick]

Yes I agree, but it's so hard to get right.

Agreed. Previous versions with this feature felt unfair with more fouls given against the player than the AI. It would be lovely to see, but getting the balance right to please everyone would be impossible.

The only way around this would be to have rules you can turn off, so the individual could decide whether or not they use the feature.

 

[sfc1895]

This needs to be done, countless times playing 2010 there were occasions where you can see the player clearly handle the ball yet nothing is called. Its unrealistic because its essential rule in the game in real life. It may add to more whistle blowing causing interuption in play but still its rule is a vital component to the game in keeping it in check otherwise it would no longer be called football. You wouldnt take out offsides so why was the handball feature ever taken out when it was in the game back on the PS2. If its inconvenient for some gamers simply provide menu option to turn it off

Here are some youtube clicks showing what Im talking about in pes2010 that was overlooked because the rule is not implemented where the player gains clear advantage with the usage of his hand.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1K9FD-FnbX0

i disagree. imagine its the 90th minute of the online champions league final. you have hit the post twice and its 1 1 .... now your oppponent smacks one and it hits your defenders hand and you can do nothing about it. that would be unfair

 

[Ultimate777]

Like savic correctly said it can work like the previous versions where only attackers handball play is whistled. Otherwise there wouldnt be a fair balance of preventing penalties in situations which you just described.