For the best lawn care in cedar park, please visit our sponsor at lawn service cedar park They are a local lawn care and landscaping company that provide services in such as lawn care, lawn mowing, weeding, and landscape maintenance in Cedar Park, Austin, Round Rock, and Leander area. They are located at:

Lawn Care Service of Cedar Park 100 E Whitestone Blvd Ste 148, #166 Cedar Park, TX 78613 (512) 595-0884

The Evolution of Pro Evo by Dave Castro

Dave Castro

Registered User
The Evolution of Pro by Dave Castro

Dear PESGaming Members & Guests,

Amigos, this is my first post which I supposes means that right now I'm loosing my forum virginity. Some of you might actually take part and others will just watch. Whichever group you happen to be, I hope this self indulgent mini essay brings as much pleasure to you as it did to the first girl I had sex with. For one thing, it has already gone on much longer…

I have been a voyeur on these forums now since the release of Pro Evo 2009. For the most part the discussions seem to be conducted in a very friendly matter. Well, that is until someone dares offer an alternative view on the latest Evo release from Konami or an opinion on why FIFA is better. At this point certain people become a tad abusive or dismissive in their replies which is a shame because after all, it’s an opinion and as such cannot be right or wrong. Unless of course you are actually suggesting that FIFA is a better football simulation which is just downright ludicrous. If you believe that then you deserve to be put up against the wall and shot in the head three times. (Calm down, I’m only joking. Once would be sufficient…)

Let’s get the “I’ve been a playing Pro Evo since its ISS days…” out of the way. I’ve played and owned them all expect of course that bastard child of a release called Pro Evo 2008 which for me was just FIFA in disguise. Thankfully with the release of 2009 there actually seems to be an Evolution happening again within the franchise. Up to the best game yet of the series in Pro Evo 5, this gradual evolution was apparent. Number 6 while still a good game was a step backwards and 2008 was like the fat girl that we’ve all boned – it may have happened but she exists only as a bad memory. With 2009 things are beginning to move in the right direction once again. I am of course referring to offline single player mode, and in particular the Master League, as I haven’t played online for various reasons: the best one being I didn’t have an internet connection.

My major complaint about Pro Evo and the Master League was it was just too easy. The computer would back off and give you ample time to pass the ball around until you could pick the right pass. Not so in 2009. The computer presses you making the execution of my particular playing style, not dissimilar to Arsenal’s I may add, a little more difficult. Add to that now the fact that when you press X it doesn’t fly pinpoint to the feet of your nearest player, that so called “easy passes” go astray and that players don’t always make the smart runs into space you can begin to see the beginnings of a real football simulator.

Now maybe I’m dreaming a little to think that this was the intention of Konami rather then bad code but if it was then I applaud them because for me, we are edging closer to what a football simulator should be. It ain’t all about whooping the computer 10-0 every game, having your CF bang in 40 plus goals a season. Sure, it’s nice when you get those games when everything seems to go right and the goals fly in but Pro Evo has been missing those games when it doesn’t go right, when you have to actually change your favorite formation to try and win a game since its birth. For most people on earlier Evo’s it was the fact that you has missed your 20+ chances that came your way that you lost points. The smaller teams played better then the names. With 2009 though, they seem to have upped a level. The big teams are evidently harder to beat. Teams do seem to actively change their formations in an attempt to stop you. Christ, if the AI finds a formation that you seem to have difficultly breaking down half the teams in the league adopt it. It’s frustrating but it’s how it should be.

The game has its faults. I can understand when people get upset about the computer taking over control of defenders and giving away fouls but this hasn’t happened to me for a long long time. I found out that this happens when you take control of a player to tackle someone then change to another when you are close to the ball. The previously controlled player continues to run on and make a tackle that 9 times out of ten results in a foul. You want to stop this? Then pick the player you want to tackle and stick with him. If you are going to change then don’t do it too late otherwise the player will continue his mission so to speak. And that like that fat girl we were talking about earlier on, even though he knows it’s wrong, he’s still gonna do it. As for the complaint about the forward runs of your players when you have the ball that is for me justified. I wouldn’t like to see them making perfect runs all of the time but some of the positioning of the players when attacking can be woeful. The way around this is to use the 1-2 pass and make them move but the complaint is still a valid one.

The game is harder. It is different from its previous incarnations, but once you find your way and discover the formation that works for you (although like I said, it won’t work all the time!!) I believe those of you who aren’t enjoying the game but have enjoyed the previous Evo’s will find peace within 2009.

I’m currently playing my second season of ML with Ajax using a similar formation to the default one with a few tweaks here and there, a 4-5-1 and a 4-4-2 for my Formation A and B settings just in case and doing really well. Won the 2nd Division (after a dreadful start) and Cup, got promoted and now top of the League after 16 weeks with 38 goals scored and 5 conceded. Got put out of the League Cup mind in the first round and have lost 1 league game and drawn 1 so it hasn’t always been plain sailing. Real are only 3 points behind. And yes, it is and always has been on Top Player.

“But you said it was hard Boss…”

Yeah but I was talking to you. I’m the shit. :)
 

CaptainCabinet

Trapped In Cabinets
I wouldn't have bothered mate. You make some excellent points, but I doubt anyone apart from a select few will read them. Superb first post though.
 

sandaweches

Registered User
Finally someone who understands what PES is all about.
I had the exact same experience playing ML and even BAL.
Frustration because it's damn hard on Top Player especially if you start on that level on day one. it's getting used to it + the difficulty.

In my opinion, it's an awesome game. the gameplay, the challenge to score is just wonderful. Even in BAL where people complain about AI loosing the ball alot or team mates not passing. Just turn on the tele watch an EPL game and see the players expression when they make a run and the guy with the ball just decides to dribble and loose possession or even make a retarded shot. Now that frustration is the same I get when I want to earn a nice score by creating a nice run waiting for the ball, calling for it but the AI decides otherwise.

Also even when AI passes, there is no guarantee that the ball is going to connect to my feet. There are so many times when I mis-timed the run and his pass goes slightly behind me and doesn't land on my feet and I lose out on the chance. This level of accuracy and involvement is what pes has always been and luckily is still about.

But when the passes do connect and your team is behind and you execute a wonderful strike. man it's freaking AWESOME!!

I agree that it's getting close to reality football. Although it might have some minor shortcomings , there is nothing out there that can replicate that football feeling.

I guess others who don't share the same passion and/or do not understand football might not value pes09 and instead follow the hype in pointing and saying..."online Baaad, liscenses baaad, AI cheating baaaaad". Luckily for them there is Fifa.
 

Tech_Skill

Registered User
Sorry mate, but PES 2009 is no simulation.

And as i have said before, the AI doesn't outplay you, it disadvantages you, its not clever, it has one ploy, rush at whoever has the ball, if the CPU touches you, you go flying off, the ball, then run run run.

If you like the game i for one am happy someone is getting enjoyment out of it.

But comparing it to making love doesnt excuse the fact its not a next generation game, and is not an improvement over any of the PS2 versions.

8 directions of movement on consoles of this era is inexcusable and it has even worse player animation than the PS2 games. (The running animations are just dreadful)

Oh, if anyone wants to argue pro evo doesnt cheat, im happy to post links to videos on youtube proving otherwise.

This video points out the flaws in PES 2009 superbly.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=WZugfsQJhcI
 

Dale C.

Registered User
Sorry mate, but PES 2009 is no simulation.

And as i have said before, the AI doesn't outplay you, it disadvantages you, its not clever, it has one ploy, rush at whoever has the ball, if the CPU touches you, you go flying off, the ball, then run run run.

If you like the game i for one am happy someone is getting enjoyment out of it.

But comparing it to making love doesnt excuse the fact its not a next generation game, and is not an improvement over any of the PS2 versions.

8 directions of movement on consoles of this era is inexcusable and it has even worse player animation than the PS2 games. (The running animations are just dreadful)

Oh, if anyone wants to argue pro evo doesnt cheat, im happy to post links to videos on youtube proving otherwise.

This video points out the flaws in PES 2009 superbly.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=WZugfsQJhcI

Clever lad
 

Paolo :)

Registered User
Some good points, but the ML isn't exactly hard at all tbh, I went 4 seasons unbeaten in it(TP) but still nice entry :)
 

Dave Castro

Registered User
Sorry mate, but PES 2009 is no simulation.

And as i have said before, the AI doesn't outplay you, it disadvantages you, its not clever, it has one ploy, rush at whoever has the ball, if the CPU touches you, you go flying off, the ball, then run run run.

If you like the game i for one am happy someone is getting enjoyment out of it.

But comparing it to making love doesnt excuse the fact its not a next generation game, and is not an improvement over any of the PS2 versions.

8 directions of movement on consoles of this era is inexcusable and it has even worse player animation than the PS2 games. (The running animations are just dreadful)

Oh, if anyone wants to argue pro evo doesnt cheat, im happy to post links to videos on youtube proving otherwise.

This video points out the flaws in PES 2009 superbly.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=WZugfsQJhcI

Tech and Dale,

In terms of Pro Evo being a simulation you are quite right it is not. But what I was suggesting was that with 2009, in my opinion at least, it is beginning to move once again in the right direction.

I'm playing on the PC so my experience might be different to yours if you are playing on a console. I have found the AI to be quite clever at times, not run Forrest run as you say but actually to pass the ball around and wait for an opportunity. When defending it seems to cover areas much better then in previous Pro's and I have not noticed the one ploy as you say, "rush at whoever has the ball". (Perhaps I should also mention that I only patched it once when the first update from Konami came out and have not bothered since because I have no intention of playing online.)

Graphics wise though you are spot on: for this day and age it is appalling. Only the boys that are so far up Seabass's ass that if they had a moustache they would tickle his throat could argue against yon point. They have become lazy since Pro Evo 5 and I hope that Konami begins to take note otherwise I think some so-called hardcore fans may defect to the dark side. If FIFA becomes better then Pro Evo then I will play it but personally I can't see EA ever getting past the same on engine they rehash time and time again for all their sport games. We shall see...

As for the cheating, well I watched the vid on youtube (boy's got way too much time on his hands...) and I have yet to see any of the more outrageous things he shows on there. It has it faults absolutely, it ain't perfect but is there really something better out there for offline play? Can another game beat the beauty of teaming up with a mate and playing the ML co-operatively?
 

gooderz

Registered User
"because after all, it’s an opinion and as such cannot be right or wrong. Unless of course you are actually suggesting that FIFA is a better football simulation which is just downright ludicrous"

:)
 

Amateur

Registered User
Sorry mate, but PES 2009 is no simulation.

And as i have said before, the AI doesn't outplay you, it disadvantages you, its not clever, it has one ploy, rush at whoever has the ball, if the CPU touches you, you go flying off, the ball, then run run run.

If you like the game i for one am happy someone is getting enjoyment out of it.

But comparing it to making love doesnt excuse the fact its not a next generation game, and is not an improvement over any of the PS2 versions.

8 directions of movement on consoles of this era is inexcusable and it has even worse player animation than the PS2 games. (The running animations are just dreadful)

Oh, if anyone wants to argue pro evo doesnt cheat, im happy to post links to videos on youtube proving otherwise.

This video points out the flaws in PES 2009 superbly.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=WZugfsQJhcI

Agreed..

PES09 is average at best, it isn't as good as PES6 or PES5.

It haves some nice touches, like the improved "Long Ball" and "Lofted Through Balls". Which really contribute something to the gameplay.

But the Time it takes to run the Length of the pitch is an Unrealistically long process. If you watch real live Football matches you'll notice it right away. It's even more obvious when you download videos of Romario, this guy could get himself into the penalty area in no time.

Even Slow players like Del Piero and Riquelme don't take that long to run the length of the pitch.

It seems like Konami literally stretched the pitch, forcing us into having to run run run in order to get inside the penalty area. I think this is a key flaw in what could have been a fairly solid Football Sim.

Because of the FACT that there's so much Time and Space on the pitch, you are not forced into Thinking Quickly, and as a result the game is less responsive. It doesn't haves the same feeling of Timing.

Plus, the dribbling movements where much better in the PS2 version of PES6, it felt much more Natural and fluid, more responsive, more realistic.

I think PES09 can be an enjoyable game at times, maybe for some 3 or 4 matches, but it doesn't haves the same replay value as before. The Next Gen PES may look the part, but doesn't feels the part.

Whereas the Old Gen PES never looked the part, but always felt the part. Is it possible to have Graphics and Feeling and Responsiveness on the same package??
 

ykl

Registered User
Great post, as always i would like to mentioned that the game play in pes09 definitely is the most realism ever presentation than previous pes version, but not the best, if you compare to pes 5 or pes6. Every pes fans have their own mind , feelings and opinion, therefore please respect each other and enjoy the game......Happy new year to all pes fans.
 

Tech_Skill

Registered User
Each to their own, If people wanna play a game with,

-Out of date rosters
-Bugs all over the place, in both next generation and PS2 versions
- A so called next generation game with worse player animations than PS2 version. lmao
-The ability to run though entire defenses with one player, sometimes the AI even moving out of the way to allow you a one on one
-Ramped up AI cheating/scripting of games because konami hasnt created an AI which can outplay any decent player
-The AI being either superhuman or fucking awful, rarely any in between
- No control of weighting of passes and through balls, because according to people on this forum, pressing x and the cpu passing it for you is as realistic as it gets (lmao)
-Shocking ball effects and commentary
-Appalling online bugs are well documented
-Its a next generation game where you can only move and pass in 8 directions, but according to some, this is just like real football
-The master league is the same old shitty unchanged crap since PES3, you still have to use points instead of real money (im waiting for someone to tell me EA have the licenses to real money lmao), cant change teams mid season and a champions league mode which isnt integrated into ML
-A champions league mode with unlicensed teams
-The edit mode is worse than PES 6 for fucks sake, this is meant to be next generation.

Despite all this, if you believe this is the best game on the market and that konami are moving in right direction, please do not complain when PES 2010 is another waste of time and energy, with the same old horrible player animations, arcade gameplay and same old master league.

If people want to buy shite for the sake of some blind loyalty, what makes them think somehow seabass is gonna turn it around and give the people what they have been asking for,for years now.

PES 2009 is not acceptable given the power of XBOX and PS3, if anything the game should have moved into another league from the old ps2 games, not got worse.
 

Red Owl

Registered User
This board is just becoming a place for people to REPEATEDLY say whether they do or do not enjoy the game. Occasionally explaining why.

The reason, surely, there is a thread at the top for people to say they don't like the game is so that there aren't tons of identical threads. This repeaed arguing is moving the proper threads, such as genuine questions people have about the game, off the first page.
 

Blugh

Registered User
As far as i'm concerned, the scripting and animations are PES's biggest flaws. Nothing annoys me more when you get a nice 3 goal lead only to have the AI/Script do some funny shit and make your players incapable of doing anything other than look like idiots and have the cpu score a cheap cheap cheap goal:realmad: Other than that, great game.
 

Dave Castro

Registered User
Apologies to Dale, missed the sarcastic tone. :rolleyes:

Tech,

As I said, the faults you describe are for me anyway in my experience, not apparent on the PC version. Certainly not to the degree you are suggesting. I am not blind to Pro's faults and I can see from your posts you don't like the game, which is fine. What i said is there a better game out there just now? Are you saying that you think FIFA is? If so, then you are of course entitled to your opinion. But my original post was about the evolution of Pro and was/is not meant to turn into yet another thread pointing out Pro's weaknesses which, it most certainly has and by now everyone is aware of. :erm:

But thanks for your input. It's always nice to hear what people think about the game.
(Did I the tone right Dale? ;) )
 
Top