You guys are right. I get so pissed when I'm playing online Poker and I can't cheat. I mean, it would be more realistic if I could have an extra deck in my sleeve or shoe. Also, when I'm playing my Baseball video game, I really want to get my players 'roided up. I mean, it happens in real life, so it's a part of the sport, right?
But seriously, however you view it, diving shouldn't be represented in a video game. Having it in a video game is practically supporting it. "HEY, check out the NEW Diving feature! Dive like your favorite players! Great fun!"
And for those arguing for a realistic 'football sim', you should know refs don't pull out automatic yellows for 95% of the dives. In fact, I would say diving succeeds 40%, while 50% not being called, and only 10% being booked.
Diving is destroying the prestige of the sport. In fact, I know many of the criticisms of Americans, as bias as they might be, is the fact that there is diving. And now diving is ruining PES. This makes EA Sports seem like the lesser evil.