Best on PS1 = International Superstar Soccer Pro Evolution 2
Agreed this second one was pretty astonishing. I remember playing it on the day it was released and thinking how on the earth have Konami improved on perfection.
Best on PS2 = PES5 - I think all the PS2 version were pretty good but Pes1 & 2 started to look dated when 3,4 & 5 had come around. The best comes down to personal taste although Pro Evo 3 and 5 stick out for me.
Best on PS3??? I don't think that we're quite there yet with PES2011, but not far off. It's certainly the best pro evo for a good number of years.
Nowhere near there, while 2011 is better than all the other crap that we have seen before it, it is being measured against incarnations of pro evo that aren't even suitable to be a dog's dinner, woeful in every sense. Pro evo 2011 is a turn in the right direction and nothing more but the player movement, shooting even the nets are all a considerable way away from where they need to be and once they get rectified then the game will begin to resemble the legend it once was.
The games on PS1, from ISS Pro 98 through to ISSPE2, were simply incredible. The graphics, sound, and presentation were poor at best, but the gameplay was simply streets ahead of anything else.
Yep, for sure, the gameplay on these was so jawdroppingly amazing that the graphics were not an issue in the slightest, ever. On the commentary side, if anyone ever played Actua Soccer 1 (1994-5) on ps1, you'll know that Barry Davies' commentary was amazing.
FIFA have started to look better ever since Konami dropped the ball on the next gen, all the way through PS1 and PS2 Fifa received their regular October ass whupping, it was embarassing, not even a contest.