What reason would he have to lie? Let's look at this here. The "only" reason I think he would possibly lie, would be to annoy you - because it does, and you take people's opinions too seriously it seems. Now. I highly doubt he's "lying" for the simple fact, I don't think he'd go out of his way and waste his time - plus his response seems very genuine and detailed, reflecting his opinion.
It could even be argued it is you, Micho, who is lying. Because I also doubt that these problems arise "every single time" that you play the game, as you suggest. As Steve has said, you can quite easily adjust the settings for PES 2012, to adopt a fully manual approach if you feel the AI is wrongfully assisting your passes etc.
Simply put Micho, calm down, and accept that other people genuinely enjoy PES 2012. I, myself, am enjoying PES 2012, or at least what I've played of it so far. Sure, not every single facet of the game is amazing, but the good outweighs the bad, and to me, that's what makes it playable, and one of the better PES editions in recent years.
Don't berate others for their opinions simply because you don't agree with them. Don't accuse them of lying either, especially when it's apparent that they're not. Be more welcoming of other's perspectives.