Ignorance is bliss g221911g?
If you honestly think Fifa is less scripted, you're mistaken. With fear of destroying the game for you, at least it did for me once I was made aware of it, is that Fifa is only about 1 on 1 duels. The rest of your defenders don't move at all in accordance to the defender you're pressuring opposition with, and there are always huge holes to exploit.
Have fun, if you're able to...
Maybe Sabatasso.
All I know is that when my opponent makes a pass, my players aren't frozen (when I'm controlling them) or deliberately running away from the ball. And the ball isn't magically attached to the attacker in FIFA. And I can intercept passes when I'm standing in front of the ball in FIFA. And autopass doesn't mean forcefield in FIFA.
I haven't found the game to be strictly one on one duels although it's definitely more prevalent than in PES.
In fact, I'm able to defend very well with Arsenal against Barca, Madrid, City, Spain, Barca, Madrid, Barca, Madrid, and Barca.
I find the game punishes bad decisions much more, and the game flows much more organically than in PES. There are tons of little things as well. The manual pass is actually manual. Switch player actually switches to the correct player. etc.
I'm having fun for now thanks. Maybe as I go on, more flaws will emerge. Maybe not.
EDIT: How could I not mention the shooting????