For the best lawn care in cedar park, please visit our sponsor at lawn service cedar park They are a local lawn care and landscaping company that provide services in such as lawn care, lawn mowing, weeding, and landscape maintenance in Cedar Park, Austin, Round Rock, and Leander area. They are located at:

Lawn Care Service of Cedar Park 100 E Whitestone Blvd Ste 148, #166 Cedar Park, TX 78613 (512) 595-0884

Overrated players: Martins!!!

Stormrider

Stormrider

Registered User
Ali_BWFC said:
Young players are generally rated lower to give them room for development in ML.
Click to expand...

That's exactly why and it's been such a huge problem and is 1 reason that stops Konami from being a more realistic sim. Player development has always been way off in the magic league (I refuse to call it by the proper name until Konami gets their shit together). Common sense shows that you should never gimp a ton of players just to compensate for the bogus development in the magic league. It would make far more sense to tone down player development to a more realistic level. I mean for the longest time I was so sick of seeing Maxi Rodriguez develop to an average of 95 (literally he had 95 in every department!) despite being 28 years of age, which is when players usually peak and either level out for a bit or start declining. That didn't make any sense to Konami though. They figured a player that no one was really making too much fuss about, who showed not a single sign of drastically improving, should development into a legend in a matter of months.

Then you have players who get higher ratings then 99 now and you just lose all hope. Big reason why many of us has never touched the ML is because this fantasy bs is just too much to take in. Really the main thing Konami needs is hiring someone with common sense. For the past few years, not a single soul there showed any signs of common sense and honestly even only 1 guy will do. Just 1 guy with common sense to speak up and say "no sir imo removing the league mode is a idiotic idea" or "no sir although Maxi Rodriguez is a decent player he shows absolutely no signs of rapidly becoming a legend in the game." That 1 guy with common sense can help Konami bring Pes back to where it belongs.
 
O

oziz14

Registered User
Ali_BWFC said:
I know, but the same rule applies. Just because Sneijder and Lampard are better shooters on the whole, doesn't mean they're more powerful.
Obviously, this doesn't just apply to Martins. You could find a player in the Championship with better shot power than these guys - but he might not consistently hit the target as much as Sneijder and Lampard, because they are BETTER shooters. Can you see where I'm coming from?
Click to expand...

Of course I know what you mean, but you are talking in real life not PES and in general...two things which I don't have a problem with.

My problem is with MARTINS because he is never a powerful shooter, plus in PES (or any game), when you have a shot power of 87 I don't think you need accuracy.

I know that Younes Kaboul has a more powerful shot than Messi, but does that means he is a better shooter?
 
Sminky

Sminky

Registered User
soc160 said:
Firstly, that statement is about Totti is utterly ridiculous, he started every game in that tournament, was subbed off early against USA because they went down to ten men and he isn't know for his pace and tracking back, he scored the penalty agaisnt Australia in the last minute and was widely recognised as having a good tournament.

Secondly, Ribery wasn't voted in the team, and one match shouldn't make that, but the main point is this was six years ago, so to those arguing the case of Ribery based on this, it was a long time ago, his talent is there but whether he shines every time is a different story, I personally think he is over-rated , in real life too.
Click to expand...

Its not ridiculous, its factually incorrect, I got Gilardino mixed up with Totti. Both look like mincing fops so you can excuse the mistake I'm sure. He had the most assists as well judging by the stats, so he indeed warranted his place.

As for Ribery, he didn't have a bad World Cup but this point does seem rather redundant.

The thread on the whole is an interesting read but its become a dichotomy of logic and nonsense. Case in point, Sneijder is a powerful striker of the ball but he's gone off the boil in recent times, doesn't diminish his ability to shoot and the sheer power he generates, just means his ability to remain consistent has.
 
8

8salacious9

Registered User
If we judge international level then shouldn't messi be one of the worse players? Even pele said messi isn't the best because he's only good at barca..
 
muscularmatt

muscularmatt

Registered User
Didn't Pele also say that an African nation would have won the world cup by the year 2000? And a ton of other fucking stupid stuff?
 
oggmeista

oggmeista

Registered User
suhailio said:
Pato was definitely THE most over-rated player in PES12 & in PES11 it was Arshavin, who they made better than Messi according to me & my friend. I have yet to come accross some really over-rated players in this version so far but some of the best players like Ronaldo are just unplayable. Oh yeah, Eto'o seems to be way too good aswell.

What makes me laugh is how defenders like David Luiz have better "defence" stats than the likes of Sergio Ramos. I must agree with the fact that Konami have their favourite players. I think the maker is a Barcelona fan, that's pretty obvious.

I also laugh at how some players continue to have high ratings regardless of whether having poor seasons or not. Maxi Rodriguez for example has ridicolously good ratings every PES, no way as realistic as they should be. And this is coming from a Liverpool fan.
Click to expand...

I don't think Pato was THAT overrated somewhat but the "most?" hmm but I did buy him in the 2012 game on my master league where i proceeded to achieve the premiership title followed by a double the following season and he was my star man..)

But regarding this thread..I don't see what is the BIG problem if your not happy with a players statistics change them!! easy enough :)

And on that topic.. I would like some information my PES 2012 has been edited so many times to a point wherby im pretty damn happy with the players stats for the whole EPL....and as well I changed starting line ups formations and edited the strategies so that every team has 4 formations normal ie default or Real // Alternative tactic formation/ /Defensive //and attack where most teams have either 4 or 5 players in the front line..these are changed with the buttons so can change them on the fly...My question though is where is the data for these team set up options stored..I know its not where the players are stored because trying to import the 2012 database into pes 2013 does not import the team strategies which let me tell you took me a long time to make...I appologise to admins for going somewhat of topic ) thx
 
S

Soccerdude

Registered User
I haven't read all the posts in the topic but what I think is few years back Martins was on the cover of PES so they at Konami rate him highly.
 
B

brashythejambo

Registered User
Nani

How can he be rated a 90 overall he is probably the most inconsistent player on the planet.Absolutely brilliant when he is on top form but hardly ever is so i think it makes his rating a mockery.
 
S

Soccerdude

Registered User
brashythejambo said:
Nani

How can he be rated a 90 overall he is probably the most inconsistent player on the planet.Absolutely brilliant when he is on top form but hardly ever is so i think it makes his rating a mockery.
Click to expand...

Well you said it yourself. he is very good on top form ....thats what the form arrows are for when the form arrow is a downward purple the players perform pretty badly.
 
G

gaurav

Registered User
don't think nani deserves 90,he is playing poorly in epl(currently),85 is far better for nani than 90.
 
Sminky

Sminky

Registered User
brashythejambo said:
Nani

How can he be rated a 90 overall he is probably the most inconsistent player on the planet.Absolutely brilliant when he is on top form but hardly ever is so i think it makes his rating a mockery.
Click to expand...

The overall rating does not account for consistency so while 90 seems high, its his overall technical and physical prowess. Yes before someone mentions the form the stat, we've already established how redundant this is. Its a percentile equation not a representative establishing of a players actual consistency.

What each player needs are 3 ratings technical, physical and attitude - with the latter being the most important capturing form based on big match occasions, versatility, willingness to sit on the bench and a general attitude, placid, determined, aggressive etc.
 
muscularmatt

muscularmatt

Registered User
Form or consistency is such a pivotal factor in football, that's never really been adequately covered in any football game. Can't remember who, but someone on this site suggested a two tier RPG style average/maximum type stat model for players, which I'd love to see.

But yeah, and what Sminky said. More 'mental' attributes.
 
Ali

Ali

It is happening again
I'd like them to do some sort of "live season" type thing, where the player's attributes reflect their real life form.
 
muscularmatt

muscularmatt

Registered User
They'd fuck it up though. You'd have a little Japanese guy watching ten minutes of football highlights a week on some crappy online stream and basing it on that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top