You seem to think input lag and slowdown is a minor issue. Its not. Input lag breaks everything you try to do. Its so massive that it doesn't allow you play the game properly on any level. I've had input lag online, so I know what I'm talking about there.
My point is the PS3 is broken because of input lag. I'm saying the Xbox doesn't have this(regardless of some rare games online), it has minor problems and its not broken. You say input lag doesn't matter, that passing, shooting, etc, and other things are broken anyway. I don't see how you can judge those properly, if you can't even do any of that properly by default because of input lag. Input lag has a direct impact on these features. But, you said input lag is not a problem in terms of this and that they are fundamental problems independently. That makes no sense to me how they are independent, but I took you up on those points about passing, etc, and decided to ignore input lag to argue your point. I have no input lag, so I can judge these without my judgement being dramatically ruined by input lag. I argued those points about passing, etc, based on the Xbox.
I'll argue with anyone who does not have input lag that the game is not broken. It may have problems, but not broken. Obviously, some of that is subjective but I don't see how someone with input lag can have a clear mind about them to begin with, when in fact that breaks everything. So yes, I'll argue that passing, shooting, throughball or anything else are not fundamental problems, if at all, on a basic level because of the Xbox. Input lag is on such a more basic level, that it ruins all those things, so I don't even see how you can even judge them properly this year on the PS3. Thats why I say the fundamental problems are on PS3. Input lag makes the game broken, I don't have so I CAN INDEPENDENTLY judge passing, etc, properly and IMO don't find them broken.
You use the lack of Xbox users supporting my claims as proof I'm wrong. Where are the Xbox users contradicting me either about the game not being broken? Broken is the key word there, not minor problems that can be fixed with a patch. I'm more than happy to engage in debate with any of them. You'll say there are fundamental problems independent of "minor" input lag and slowdown. I disagree, I don't see how input lag is independent if it has a direct impact on everything. The opinion of whether the game has fundamental problems when no input lag exists then becomes independent and yes, I'll argue it's not broken and I'm interested to see who thinks it is.
As for the threads you mentioned:
1. I was talking about who is mostly talking about the game being broken, not people complaining of problems of which I've posted in the rage thread a few times myself.
2. It's impossible to say from most of those complaining that their problems are not stemming from input lag.
EDITED!!